Indigenous Rights Alignment Act

Summary#

Bill 76, the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples Act, 2019, would create a new Ontario law. It would give the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples force of law in Ontario and require the Ontario government to work toward making Ontario laws consistent with it. The bill’s stated goal is to achieve the Declaration’s objectives.

  • The Ontario government must take all measures necessary to make Ontario laws consistent with the Declaration, in consultation and cooperation with Indigenous peoples in Ontario.
  • The government must develop and carry out a provincial plan to achieve the Declaration’s objectives, also in consultation and cooperation with Indigenous peoples.
  • The Declaration sets out rights relating to matters including self-determination, culture, language, lands and resources, and participation in decisions that affect Indigenous peoples.
  • The Minister of Indigenous Affairs must prepare annual reports on the government’s measures and plan, and table them in the Legislature within 60 days after April 1 each year from 2020 to 2037.
  • The bill says it does not reduce existing Aboriginal and treaty rights protected by section 35 of the Constitution Act, 1982, and that it does not delay the Declaration’s application in Ontario law.

What it means for you#

  • Indigenous peoples in Ontario: The Declaration would have force of law in Ontario. It includes rights and state obligations on subjects such as consultation before certain decisions and projects, and consent in some situations. How those provisions would apply in particular cases is not set out in the bill.
  • Ontario government: It would have duties to work on legal consistency, develop and implement a plan, and report annually. Consultation and cooperation with Indigenous peoples are required for the first two duties.
  • Other residents, organizations and businesses: The bill does not itself set out a new application or approval process for them. But Ontario laws would be subject to the Declaration’s force of law, so the effects could depend on how the Declaration applies to those laws.
  • The bill does not itself set a tax, fee, fine, benefit, or dedicated funding amount.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The government would have to take measures, develop and implement a plan, and produce annual reports. The bill gives no cost estimate, staffing level, or funding source.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not explain how conflicts between the Declaration and existing Ontario laws would be resolved, or what happens if a law is found inconsistent.
  • It does not set out how people could enforce the Declaration in court, or what remedies would be available.
  • It does not define how consultation and cooperation must work, or how Indigenous peoples would take part in the plan.
  • It does not set deadlines for making laws consistent, apart from the annual reporting schedule.
  • The supplied material does not include the current Ontario laws that could be affected, so their interaction with the new Act cannot be checked here.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that giving the Declaration force of law, alongside a duty to review consistency, gives the government a clear legal direction rather than leaving implementation only as a stated goal.
  • The required plan and annual reports could provide a way to organize the work and show what measures the government has taken.
  • Requiring consultation and cooperation makes Indigenous participation part of the bill’s legal duties.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the bill gives a wide-ranging declaration force of law without explaining how courts or government would apply it to specific laws and disputes.
  • The duty to take “all measures necessary” is broad, but the bill does not set out priorities, deadlines for legal changes, or a process for deciding what measures are needed.
  • The plan and consultation duties could require substantial public resources, but the bill gives no cost estimate or funding plan.

Votes

The recorded vote on this bill, member by member.

  1. Division No. 2019032103

    Passed91 members voted

    Second Reading of Bill 76

    FOR · 91

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    91For

    • PC56
    • NDP32
    • Liberal2
    • Green1

    0Against