Summary#
Bill 205, the Protecting Renters from Illegal Evictions Act, 2020, would amend Ontario’s Residential Tenancies Act, 2006, legal aid laws and the Ministry of Municipal Affairs and Housing Act. Its stated goal is to address certain evictions based on a landlord’s or purchaser’s plans for the unit, and to provide legal representation to tenants who receive notices for reasons unrelated to their conduct.
- Landlords would have to use the Landlord and Tenant Board’s approved forms for these notices. A notice on another form would count as not given, and the Board would have to refuse an eviction application based on it.
- Notice periods for personal-use, purchaser-use, demolition, conversion and repair or renovation cases would increase to six months. Landlords or purchasers giving personal-use notices would have to intend residential occupation for at least two years.
- For repair or renovation notices, landlords would have to include copies of all valid approvals needed for the work. The approvals would have to authorize work extensive enough to require the unit to be empty.
- If the Board finds bad faith in one of the covered cases, it would have to order payment to the former tenant of the greater of 12 months’ rent or $35,000. The bill also changes the available remedies, including possible return to the unit or another unit.
- The Board would have to keep a register of these applications, notify the Minister of orders, and publish annual reports with unit addresses and case outcomes, but not the parties’ names. The Minister would have to take steps the Minister considers appropriate to check good faith.
- Legal aid would have to provide representation before the Board to people who request it after receiving a termination notice for a reason unrelated to their conduct. Financial eligibility rules and required contributions would not apply.
What it means for you#
- Tenants receiving covered notices: You would get at least six months’ notice under the changed rules. If a landlord used an unapproved form, the Board would have to treat the notice as not given and refuse an eviction application based on it.
- Tenants alleging bad faith: You would have two years to apply to the Board instead of one. If the Board found bad faith, the bill would require the monetary award above. Depending on whether the unit was vacant, the Board could order that you return to it, receive the landlord’s next available unit at your former rent, or have the new tenant charged your former legal rent. The bill’s amendments also address moving and storage expenses, but their application depends on related legislation taking effect.
- Landlords and purchasers: Personal-use notices would require an intention to occupy the unit for at least two years. A landlord giving a repair or renovation notice would need the required approvals when giving the notice.
- Tenants receiving other no-fault notices: If the reason is unrelated to your conduct, you could request legal representation at the Board without meeting the usual financial eligibility rules or contributing to the cost. The bill does not require you to apply for legal aid for the service to be available; it says the service must be provided to those who request it.
- Taxpayers and the public: The Board, Ministry and legal aid provider would have new duties. The bill does not create a new independent agency or a general eviction-approval process.
Money#
The bill requires new public services and administrative work, but no cost estimate is available in the supplied material.
- Legal aid would have to provide representation without financial eligibility tests or required contributions.
- The Board would have to maintain the register and publish annual reports; the Minister would have to take steps to check good faith. The bill gives no staffing or cost figures.
- The required bad-faith payment would be paid by the landlord to the former tenant, not described as a public benefit.
What is unclear#
- The Residential Tenancies Act and other amended Acts were not supplied, so the bill’s full effect against current law—including how its changes interact with existing rules—could not be verified.
- The bill does not set out how the Minister must check good faith, what evidence is needed, or how former tenants will be contacted.
- It does not explain how the Board would handle the published addresses, or whether any exceptions apply.
- The legal aid duty covers notices for reasons unrelated to a tenant’s conduct, but the bill does not define that phrase or set out how requests for representation would be handled.
- No start date or current status of the bill is provided in the supplied material. No publicly available information.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to make it harder to use personal-use or renovation notices as a pretext for removing a tenant.
- Longer notice periods and required approvals could give tenants more time and evidence to respond to covered notices.
- A mandatory financial penalty and other possible remedies could make a bad-faith finding more consequential.
- Legal representation could help tenants understand and present their case at the Board, regardless of income.
Case against#
- Treating any failure to use the approved form as no notice could prevent an eviction application even where the error is technical.
- Six-month notice periods and the two-year personal-occupation requirement could limit landlords’ ability to regain or renovate a unit on the timelines they intend.
- The bill requires legal representation without eligibility limits but provides no funding estimate or service-capacity details.
- The Minister’s duty to take measures to confirm good faith has no set process or standards in the bill, while the public reports would include unit addresses.