Summary#
Bill 58, the Protecting Renters from Illegal Evictions Act, 2022, would amend Ontario’s Residential Tenancies Act, 2006, Legal Aid Services Act, 2020 and Ministry of Municipal Affairs and Housing Act. Its stated goal is to change rules for certain evictions based on personal use, repairs, demolition or conversion, and to provide legal representation to affected tenants.
- Landlords giving these notices would have to use the Landlord and Tenant Board’s approved form. Without it, the notice would not count, and the Board would have to refuse an eviction application based on it.
- For personal-use notices, the bill would set a two-year occupancy period for the landlord, family member or purchaser, and change the notice period from 60 days to six months. It would also change a related compensation amount from one month’s rent to three months’ rent.
- For repair, renovation, demolition or conversion notices, landlords would have to provide copies of necessary valid approvals. For repairs or renovations, those approvals would have to authorize work extensive enough to require the unit to be vacant. The notice period would change from 120 days to six months.
- If the Board found bad faith on a former tenant’s application, it would have to order the landlord to pay the greater of 12 months’ rent or $35,000. The Board could also order the former tenant back into the unit, into the landlord’s next vacant unit at the former rent, or require the landlord to charge the new tenant the former legal rent.
- The Board would keep a register of these applications, notify the Minister of orders, and publish annual reports with application addresses and outcomes, but not the parties’ names. The Minister would have to take measures they consider appropriate to check good faith.
- Legal Aid Ontario would have to provide free representation at the Board to people who request it after receiving a termination notice for a reason unrelated to their conduct. The usual income eligibility rules would not apply.
What it means for you#
- Renters receiving these notices: The bill would lengthen some notice periods and require landlords to use the Board’s form. Repair and renovation notices would need to include copies of necessary approvals. The bill does not ban these types of evictions.
- Former tenants alleging bad faith: They would have two years, rather than one, under the affected provisions to apply to the Board. If the Board found bad faith, a payment of at least $35,000 or 12 months’ rent, whichever is greater, would be mandatory. Other listed remedies would be available for the Board to order.
- Landlords: They would have to meet the form and document requirements. A bad-faith finding could lead to the mandatory payment and other orders.
- People seeking legal help: Those who received a notice for a reason unrelated to their conduct could request legal representation at the Board without meeting usual income rules or contributing to its cost.
- Taxpayers and the public: The Board and Ministry would have new record-keeping, reporting and checking duties. The bill does not set out their staffing or operating arrangements.
Money#
No cost information is in the available material.
- Legal Aid Ontario would have to provide representation without income tests or client contributions; no funding estimate is given.
- The Board and Ministry would have new duties, but the bill gives no staffing or cost estimate.
- Landlords found to have acted in bad faith would have to pay the greater of 12 months’ rent or $35,000 to the former tenant.
What is unclear#
- The current Acts were not supplied, so the full effect of the amendments against current law could not be checked. In particular, the bill changes conditions in section 52 related to demolition or conversion, but the full section is not available here.
- The bill does not define “good faith” or explain what evidence the Minister would use to check it.
- It does not set out how the Minister’s checks would work, how former tenants would be identified, or how quickly they would be notified.
- The bill does not explain how legal representation would be arranged or how Legal Aid Ontario would meet the new duty.
- It gives no details about how the Board would maintain the register or protect the privacy of addresses published in its reports.
Case for#
- A longer notice period and required approvals could give tenants more time and information when a landlord seeks a unit for personal use or plans work.
- The approved-form rule could make notices clearer and prevent eviction applications based on notices that do not meet the required form.
- Mandatory compensation after a bad-faith finding, along with possible return-to-housing orders, could give former tenants stronger remedies.
- Free legal representation and public reporting could help tenants use the Board process and make these applications more visible.
Case against#
- The bill creates significant duties for the Board, Ministry and Legal Aid Ontario without stating how they would be funded or carried out.
- The Minister’s duty to take measures to check good faith leaves the methods and level of scrutiny to the Minister’s judgment.
- The public reports would include rental-unit addresses and application outcomes. The bill does not explain how privacy risks from that information would be handled.
- The two-year occupancy rules, longer notice periods and required approvals could make some personal-use or repair-related evictions harder to carry out, even when the landlord’s reason is genuine. The bill does not explain how any disputes about those requirements would be resolved beyond the Board process.