Transit-oriented development bill expands charges

Summary#

Bill 197, the COVID-19 Economic Recovery Act, 2020, became Ontario law as Chapter 18 of the Statutes of Ontario, 2020. It amends many existing laws and creates the Transit-Oriented Communities Act, 2020 and the Modernizing Ontario for People and Businesses Act, 2020. Its stated goal is to support economic recovery and modernize rules; that goal is not a guaranteed result. Some provisions took effect at Royal Assent, while others require a later proclamation.

  • Environmental assessments: The bill changes which projects are covered: regulations can designate projects for assessment, and a streamlined assessment process is set out for a future class of designated projects. The Minister can require some projects to use the more detailed process. Existing approved class assessments continue during the transition.
  • Development and municipal charges: It expands the services municipalities can fund through development charges. It also lets local municipalities charge for community benefits on qualifying development, subject to limits and rules, including exemptions for buildings under five storeys or with fewer than 10 homes.
  • Land use and transit: The Minister gains stronger zoning-order powers on specified land outside the Greenbelt, including powers related to affordable housing and development agreements. The new transit-oriented communities law allows land to be designated for projects tied to four named priority transit projects. It removes hearings of necessity for certain expropriations.
  • Borrowing costs and municipal meetings: For eligible payday loans in default, lenders may charge up to 2.5% monthly interest on outstanding principal, not compounded; a dishonoured-payment fee is generally capped at $25 and may be charged only once per loan. Municipal procedure by-laws may allow electronic meeting participation and proxy votes.
  • Other changes: It permits new ways to take part in provincial-offence proceedings, changes the justice-of-the-peace appointment process, and creates regulatory-cost reporting and offset rules for businesses. It also makes changes to school administration, drainage, marriage-licence validity during an emergency, and other areas.

What it means for you#

  • Developers and municipalities: Municipalities may impose qualifying community benefits charges and development charges for a broader list of services. A community benefits charge is capped by a percentage of land value to be set by regulation; at least 60% of the money in its special account at the start of each year must be spent or allocated that year.
  • Residents near proposed landfills: Under the detailed environmental-assessment process, the proponent must obtain support from the municipality where the site would be located and certain nearby municipalities. The bill uses a 3.5-kilometre test, subject to possible regulation changes.
  • Property owners: For specified provincial highway expropriations and expropriations for designated transit-oriented community projects, hearings of necessity under the Expropriations Act do not apply. The Minister may set up a process to receive and consider property-owner comments, but the bill does not require one.
  • Borrowers: If a lender breaks the new default-interest rule, the borrower is liable only for repaying the advance, not borrowing costs or interest. If the lender breaks the dishonoured-payment fee rule, the borrower is liable only for the advance, not borrowing costs or default charges. These rules do not apply to loans already in existence when the provisions took effect.
  • Municipal councillors: A municipality or Toronto may permit electronic participation and proxy votes through its procedure by-law. Proxy rules limit each member to acting for one absent member at a time and restrict proxy votes where the appointing member has a known financial conflict.
  • Businesses: When submitting documents to a ministry under a covered rule, a business may submit them electronically. Ministers must consider listed principles when developing covered rules, and regulatory-cost analysis and offsets apply in specified circumstances.
  • General public: The bill does not itself guarantee faster assessments, more housing, lower costs, or new transit construction.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill authorizes the Minister to invest in, support, or develop transit-oriented community projects through entities, with required approvals for certain investments and borrowing. No spending estimate or funding commitment is given.
  • The bill allows remuneration and expenses for the Provincial Land and Development Facilitator, but gives no amount.
  • Community benefits and development charges are payments tied to development; the bill gives no forecast of how much municipalities will collect.
  • The new regulatory-cost law requires offsets in prescribed cases, but the offset formulas and any overall savings or costs are not provided.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied material does not include the parent Acts in full, so the complete changes against current law could not be verified.
  • Some major environmental-assessment changes depend on regulations or proclamation. The bill does not provide the full list of projects that will be covered or the detailed streamlined process.
  • The percentage cap for community benefits charges, some charge rules, and some payday-loan limits can be set or changed by regulation; those details are not included.
  • The bill does not require the Minister to create a comment process for the specified expropriations, or explain how any such process would work.
  • The law gives broad powers to create entities for transit-oriented projects, but the supplied text does not identify which entities will be created, their governance, or their costs.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to support development and infrastructure by giving municipalities more ways to fund services and by changing environmental-assessment processes.
  • A possible argument for designating projects by regulation is that assessment requirements can be focused on projects the government identifies, rather than applying broadly.
  • Electronic meetings, proxy voting, and remote participation in provincial-offence proceedings can provide alternatives to attending in person.
  • The bill adds public reporting and analysis requirements for some regulatory changes, and gives businesses an electronic way to submit documents.

Case against#

  • A possible trade-off is that limiting assessments to designated projects may leave some projects outside the Act’s assessment process; the bill does not identify all projects that will be designated.
  • The Minister’s expanded zoning and expropriation powers may reduce local or property-owner influence. For some expropriations, the usual hearings of necessity are removed, while a comment process is optional.
  • New municipal charges may increase costs for some developments. The bill’s exemptions and caps limit charges but do not show how costs will be shared or affect particular projects.
  • Key rules, costs, and oversight arrangements depend on later regulations or decisions, making the practical effects difficult to judge from the bill alone.

Votes

3 recorded votes on this bill, newest first.

  1. Division No. 2020072105

    Passed88 members voted

    Second Reading of Bill 197

    FOR · 59AGAINST · 29

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    59For

    • PC59

    29Against

    • NDP22
    • Liberal6
    • Green1
  2. Division No. 2020072107

    Passed87 members voted

    Third Reading of Bill 197

    FOR · 62AGAINST · 25

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    62For

    • PC62

    25Against

    • NDP18
    • Liberal6
    • Green1
  3. Division No. 2020070803

    Passed81 members voted

    On motion by Hon. Mr. Clark, Bill 197, An Act to amend various statutes in response to COVID-19 and to enact, amend and repeal various statutes, was introduced and read…

    FOR · 59AGAINST · 22

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    59For

    • PC59

    22Against

    • NDP17
    • Liberal4
    • Green1