Housing reforms speed up building

Summary#

Bill 23, the More Homes Built Faster Act, 2022, is an enacted law: it amends nine existing Ontario statutes and creates the Supporting Growth and Housing in York and Durham Regions Act, 2022. Its stated goal is to support faster housing development; that goal is not a guarantee that more homes will be built.

  • Municipal planning rules must allow up to three homes in certain detached, semi-detached and row houses, and one more in a qualifying ancillary building, on defined urban residential land. They cannot require more than one parking space or set a minimum floor area for those homes.
  • The law reduces or removes some development, parkland and community-benefit charges, adds exemptions for certain housing, and requires municipalities to spend or allocate at least 60% of some reserve funds each year.
  • It narrows some appeal rights, expands the Ontario Land Tribunal’s powers, and limits some heritage and conservation-authority processes.
  • It requires York and Durham Regions to work on sewage projects, including the York Region sewage works project. It also allows the province to speed these projects through exemptions from environmental assessment requirements and controls on project land.
  • The province gains new powers over some municipal rental-demolition rules, heritage protections, conservation-authority fees and the Ontario Underground Infrastructure Notification System Corporation.

What it means for you#

  • Homeowners and people seeking housing: In qualifying areas, municipal official plans and zoning by-laws cannot prohibit the specified additional homes or impose the stated parking and minimum-size rules. This does not itself approve a building project or remove other legal requirements.
  • Builders and housing providers: Some new or expanded projects may face lower charges or exemptions. Affordable-unit exemptions require a 25-year affordability commitment; attainable-unit exemptions apply when the unit is first sold and are subject to criteria that may be prescribed. Non-profit housing developments and certain inclusionary-zoning units also get development-charge exemptions.
  • Municipalities: They must spend or allocate at least 60% of the starting balance in certain development-charge reserve funds, and at least 60% in parkland special accounts, annually. They also have less ability to control some site design and some residential-rental demolitions if the Minister sets limits by regulation.
  • People appealing planning decisions: Some appeals are limited to listed “specified persons” and public bodies, rather than anyone with an interest. Certain older appeals were deemed dismissed unless specified exceptions applied. This is not a blanket end to public appeals.
  • People near the York-Durham projects: The Minister may require permits for specified work on or near designated project land, require removal or alteration of some obstructions, and issue stop-work orders. The law provides compensation in some cases, but not for every loss.
  • Taxpayers and local communities: York and Durham Regions must work to develop, build and operate the sewage project. The law also requires consultation with listed Indigenous communities and interested people, but exempts the projects from the Environmental Assessment Act and the Environmental Bill of Rights process described in the law.

Money#

No publicly available information on the law’s overall public cost is included in the supplied material.

  • Municipalities may collect less in some development charges and other development-related charges. The law does not say that any savings must be passed on to homebuyers or renters.
  • Municipalities must spend or allocate 60% of certain reserve balances each year; this is not a stated requirement to spend 60% more.
  • If the Ontario Clean Water Agency is ordered to do project work, municipalities must pay its costs. The law allows regulations to set municipal cost shares, but no total project cost is given.
  • The law raises maximum fines for some home-construction licensing offences and allows administrative penalties up to $50,000, with a possible increase equal to the economic benefit gained.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied material does not include the full parent Acts, so I could not independently check every change against current law.
  • Some provisions depend on regulations, ministerial decisions or future orders. Their full reach, timing and conditions are not all set out here.
  • The law does not provide a total cost for the sewage projects, estimates of municipal revenue lost, or estimates of staffing and enforcement costs.
  • The sewage project rules require reports and consultation, but the supplied text does not set out final project designs, environmental impacts or the outcome of consultation.
  • The Act’s provisions came into force on different dates, and some required proclamation. The supplied material does not give all those dates.

Case for#

  • The law removes some planning barriers to additional homes on qualifying urban residential land and reduces charges for some kinds of housing.
  • It gives municipalities and the province tools to direct reserve funds toward infrastructure and to speed decisions at the Land Tribunal.
  • A possible argument for the York-Durham project provisions is that they set project duties, timelines and coordination powers for sewage works needed to serve the named regions.
  • Some exemptions are tied to affordability commitments or non-profit housing, rather than applying to all new units.

Case against#

  • Lower development charges and limits on parkland and community-benefit charges may leave municipalities with less revenue for services and public space; the law does not show how any gap would be filled.
  • The law narrows some appeal routes and removes environmental-assessment processes for two projects. This may reduce opportunities for review and public input, even though the Act requires consultation and reports.
  • The Minister receives broad powers over project land and permits, and may exempt provincial properties from heritage rules. The supplied text does not explain all the limits or oversight for these decisions.
  • Some housing exemptions rely on later rules or definitions, and attainable housing is not required to remain affordable after its first sale.

Votes

4 recorded votes on this bill, newest first.

  1. Division No. 2022112801

    Passed100 members voted

    Motion for closure on Third Reading of Bill 23

    FOR · 73AGAINST · 27

    73For

    • PC73

    27Against

    • NDP24
    • Liberal2
    • Green1
  2. Division No. 2022112802

    Passed105 members voted

    Third Reading of Bill 23

    FOR · 74AGAINST · 31

    74For

    • PC74

    31Against

    • NDP24
    • Liberal6
    • Green1
  3. Division No. 2022103101

    Passed108 members voted

    Motion for closure on Second Reading of Bill 23

    FOR · 74AGAINST · 34

    74For

    • PC74

    34Against

    • NDP26
    • Liberal7
    • Green1
  4. Division No. 2022103102

    Passed109 members voted

    Second Reading of Bill 23

    FOR · 75AGAINST · 34

    75For

    • PC75

    34Against

    • NDP26
    • Liberal7
    • Green1