Transit projects sped up with new powers

Summary#

Bill 222, the Ontario Rebuilding and Recovery Act, 2020, amends three existing Acts: the Building Transit Faster Act, 2020, the Public Service Works on Highways Act and the Transit-Oriented Communities Act, 2020. Its stated goal is to help move provincial transit projects forward; it became law as Chapter 35 of Ontario’s 2020 statutes.

  • Ontario can prescribe other provincial transit projects as “priority transit projects” under the first and third Acts.
  • If a utility company does not comply with certain notices or orders, a road authority may ask a Superior Court judge to order compliance or allow the road authority to do the work.
  • With the Lieutenant Governor in Council’s approval, the Minister of Infrastructure may establish, acquire, manage, participate in or otherwise deal with corporations, partnerships, joint ventures or other entities to invest in, support or develop transit-oriented community projects tied to prescribed provincial transit projects.
  • The Minister may borrow or manage financial risks for these activities only with the Minister of Finance’s written approval and arrangements by the Ontario Financing Authority, unless the Finance Minister agrees otherwise in writing.
  • The Minister may delegate these powers to Metrolinx or another prescribed public body, subject to conditions and limits set by regulation.

What it means for you#

  • Utility companies and road authorities: If a utility company fails to follow a notice or order covered by the Act, the road authority can apply to court for one of the two remedies. The judge may grant either remedy; the road authority does not get to impose it on its own.
  • Ontario government, Metrolinx and prescribed public bodies: The Minister gains powers to work through other entities on transit-oriented community projects. The bill allows delegation to Metrolinx or a prescribed public body, but does not require delegation.
  • People and businesses near transit projects: The definition of a transit-oriented community project includes development of any nature or kind and for any use connected with building or operating a station on a priority transit project. The bill does not set out a process for choosing or approving individual developments.
  • Transit users: The bill does not directly change fares, service levels or eligibility for transit services.

Money#

The bill gives the Minister powers that can involve public assets and borrowing, but the available material gives no cost estimate.

  • The Minister may invest assets in, support or develop projects through entities. The bill does not state how much money or which assets would be used.
  • Borrowing and financial-risk management require written approval from the Minister of Finance and coordination by the Ontario Financing Authority, unless the Finance Minister agrees in writing to a different arrangement.
  • Entities receiving funds from the Minister must follow an investment policy approved in writing by the Finance Minister.
  • The bill does not provide an appropriation, cost estimate, or estimate of savings or returns.

What is unclear#

  • Which additional transit projects will be prescribed, and when, is not stated in the supplied material.
  • The bill leaves important rules to future regulations, including limits on activities, powers, governance, and whether an entity is a Crown agent (part of the Crown for legal purposes).
  • It does not set out project-selection criteria, public reporting, or how affected communities would be involved.
  • “Transit-oriented community project” is broad, and the bill does not explain how its scope would be applied to particular developments.
  • The Acts being amended were not supplied in full, so the existing rules and processes—and how these changes fit with them—could not be fully checked.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to let Ontario add provincial transit projects to the priority-project rules, rather than limiting those rules to projects already named in law.
  • Giving the Minister several ways to work with corporations, partnerships, joint ventures or other entities may provide flexibility in supporting or developing transit-related projects.
  • A court remedy could help a road authority address a utility company’s failure to comply with a notice or order.

Case against#

  • The Minister’s power to create, acquire or participate in entities is broad, while many limits and governance rules are left to future regulations.
  • The bill does not specify how projects will be selected, how much public money or which assets may be used, or what public reporting will be required.
  • A road authority must apply to court to get the new remedies, and the bill does not set out how quickly an application must be heard.

Votes

3 recorded votes on this bill, newest first.

  1. Division No. 2020120301

    Passed71 members voted

    Motion for closure on Third Reading of Bill 222

    FOR · 56AGAINST · 15

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    56For

    • PC52
    • Liberal4

    15Against

    • NDP14
    • Green1
  2. Division No. 2020120302

    Passed71 members voted

    Third Reading of Bill 222

    FOR · 56AGAINST · 15

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    56For

    • PC52
    • Liberal4

    15Against

    • NDP14
    • Green1
  3. Division No. 2020102902

    Passed71 members voted

    Second Reading of Bill 222

    FOR · 49AGAINST · 22

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    49For

    • PC47
    • Liberal2

    22Against

    • NDP20
    • Green1
    • Independent1