Infrastructure powers shift to Crown

Summary#

Bill 69, Reducing Inefficiencies Act (Infrastructure Statute Law Amendments), 2023, is enacted as Chapter 5 of Ontario’s 2023 statutes. It amends the Environmental Assessment Act, the Ministry of Infrastructure Act, 2011, and several other Acts. Its stated goal is to reduce inefficiencies in infrastructure.

  • For certain undertakings under the Environmental Assessment Act, the Minister may order that the usual wait after the public comment period no longer applies. The Minister can do so only after the comment period ends.
  • The Minister may prescribe entities that cannot hold, control or acquire land, buildings, structures, related interests or fixtures, subject to exceptions in regulations.
  • When an entity is prescribed, its existing property and related interests are deemed to vest in the Crown and come under the Infrastructure Minister’s control.
  • Related amendments make property powers under several statutes subject to the new limit, including statutes for Agricorp, the Ontario Arts Council, the Ontario Financing Authority, EQAO, FSRA and the Ontario Securities Commission. The bill does not itself prescribe which entities will be covered.
  • The Infrastructure Minister and the Lieutenant Governor in Council receive powers to make regulations about exceptions, property and agreements. Some regulations about existing agreements may be retroactive.

What it means for you#

  • People commenting on covered undertakings: The comment period still must end before the Minister can make an order lifting the wait. The order applies only to that undertaking; a change to it needs a separate order.
  • Entities prescribed by regulation: They cannot hold, control or acquire the listed property, unless regulations provide an exception. Property they already own or control transfers by law to the Crown under the Infrastructure Minister’s control. The Minister may acquire property for an entity’s use, with the acquisition treated as being for government purposes.
  • People or organizations with agreements involving affected property: Regulations may change how agreements are treated, including agreements already made. The bill also says actions taken under this section or its regulations do not count as expropriation or injurious affection (a loss in property value caused by a public work) under the Expropriations Act or otherwise at law.
  • The general public: The bill does not directly create a new public service, tax, fee or benefit.

Money#

No cost estimate is provided in the available material.

  • The bill does not state a budget, staffing level or operating cost for the new powers.
  • It does not set a tax or fee. Property transfers to the Crown may affect control of assets, but the material gives no value for them.
  • Schedule 1 took effect on Royal Assent. Schedule 2 takes effect on a date set by proclamation; the material does not say whether that date has been set.

What is unclear#

  • Which entities will be prescribed, and what criteria or process the Minister will use to choose them.
  • What exceptions or conditions regulations may set, and how affected entities and agreement parties will be told or involved.
  • How existing agreements will be treated, including whether and how retroactive regulations will affect them.
  • What limits, if any, will apply to the Minister’s power to lift the wait after a comment period.
  • The parent Acts were not supplied, so I could not independently verify all existing rules or property powers against their current full text.

Case for#

  • The bill may give the government more direct control of property held by prescribed entities, which could make infrastructure property easier to coordinate.
  • Allowing the Minister to lift the wait after public comments have ended could give the government flexibility in deciding when a covered undertaking proceeds.
  • Regulations can set exceptions and address transition issues, allowing different arrangements where needed.

Case against#

  • The bill does not set criteria for deciding which entities are prescribed or when the Minister should lift the wait. Important choices are left to ministers and regulations.
  • Property transfers happen automatically when an entity is prescribed. The bill says this is not expropriation or injurious affection, and does not explain what other protections may apply to affected entities.
  • Regulations may affect agreements already made, may limit liability and, in some cases, may apply to a period before filing. That could leave agreement parties uncertain about their rights.
  • The bill does not provide cost estimates or explain how the new property and regulation powers will be administered.

Votes

The recorded vote on this bill, member by member.

  1. Division No. 2023030601

    Passed105 members voted

    Second Reading of Bill 69

    FOR · 78AGAINST · 27

    78For

    • PC72
    • Liberal5
    • Independent1

    27Against

    • NDP26
    • Green1