Prenatal Down syndrome information rule advances

Summary#

Bill 225, Harvey and Gurvir’s Law (Provision of Information Respecting Down Syndrome), 2020, would amend Ontario’s Regulated Health Professions Act, 1991. It would require the Minister to make written information about Down syndrome available, and set duties for regulated health professionals when they communicate a prenatal diagnosis. The bill’s stated goal is to address discrimination and misinformation affecting people with Down syndrome and their families.

  • The Minister must ensure the information is up to date and evidence based. It must cover life expectancy; cognitive and physical development; education and psychosocial outcomes; and family and community resources.
  • Before releasing the information, the Minister must consult health professionals with particular expertise in Down syndrome and organizations representing or advocating for people with Down syndrome.
  • The information must be available in English and French, and in any other languages the Minister considers appropriate.
  • A regulated health professional who communicates a prenatal diagnosis must give the expectant parent or parents the written information and explain the 48-hour waiting period.
  • For 48 hours after giving the information, the professional must not recommend further testing or treatment related to the diagnosis, unless the parents explicitly request it or the professional believes it is necessary during that period. The professional must also say parents may wish to wait before requesting further testing or treatment, unless the professional believes it is necessary sooner.

What it means for you#

  • Expectant parents receiving a prenatal diagnosis: You would have to be given the Minister’s written information. The bill would not require you to wait before requesting further testing or treatment; it limits what the professional may recommend during the 48-hour period, subject to the exceptions above.
  • Regulated health professionals: You would have to provide the information and explain the waiting period when communicating a prenatal diagnosis. The bill does not create a general ban on testing or treatment.
  • The Minister: You would have to arrange for the information, consultations and public availability in the required languages.
  • Public: The information would also have to be publicly available. The bill does not change eligibility for services or benefits.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill would require the Minister to arrange for the information and consultations, but gives no cost estimate or staffing details.
  • No fees, fines, spending amount or funding source are specified.

What is unclear#

  • The Regulated Health Professions Act, 1991 is not supplied, so the existing duties and how these amendments would change current law could not be verified.
  • The bill does not set standards for deciding whether information is “up-to-date” or “evidence based,” or how often it must be reviewed.
  • It does not define when further testing or treatment is “necessary” during the 48-hour period.
  • It does not set out enforcement, complaint, review or reporting processes for these duties.
  • The bill’s text says sections 2 and 3 would begin six months after Royal Assent, and the rest on Royal Assent. The materials do not say whether it received Royal Assent or provide a current status.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that families would receive written information on outcomes and resources, rather than relying only on what is said when a diagnosis is communicated.
  • Requiring consultation with experts and organizations representing people with Down syndrome could bring their knowledge into the information.
  • The 48-hour limit on recommendations could give parents time to consider the information, while allowing earlier recommendations if parents request them or the professional believes they are necessary.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the bill does not explain how the information would be kept current or how disagreements about evidence would be handled.
  • The 48-hour rule could affect the timing of professional recommendations. The exceptions may address some situations, but “necessary” is not defined.
  • The bill does not explain how compliance would be monitored or what would happen if a professional or the Minister did not meet the duties.