Prenatal Down syndrome information required

Summary#

Bill 304, Harvey and Gurvir’s Law (Providing Information about Down Syndrome to Expectant Parents, Regulated Health Professionals and the Public), 2021, would amend Ontario’s Regulated Health Professions Act, 1991. It would require the Minister to make specified written information about Down syndrome available, and require regulated health professionals covered by the Act to give it to expectant parents when communicating a prenatal diagnosis. The bill says its goal is to address misinformation and discrimination.

  • The Minister would have to ensure the information is up to date and evidence-based, and consult health professionals with expertise in Down syndrome and organizations representing or advocating for people with Down syndrome before making it available.
  • The information would have to cover life expectancy; cognitive and physical development; education and psychosocial outcomes; and resources for families and community supports.
  • The information would have to be available in English and French, and in any other languages the Minister considers appropriate.
  • A covered health professional would have to provide the Minister’s written information to expectant parents when communicating a prenatal diagnosis of Down syndrome.

What it means for you#

  • Expectant parents receiving a prenatal diagnosis: If the bill became law, the health professional communicating the diagnosis would have to provide the written information. The bill does not require particular medical advice or dictate what decision a parent makes.
  • Regulated health professionals: They would have to provide the Minister’s information in that situation. The bill does not set out a separate counselling, referral or follow-up process.
  • People with Down syndrome and their families: The bill would require specified information and resources to be made available, but does not guarantee particular services or outcomes.
  • General public: The information would be publicly available in English and French, and possibly other languages. The bill does not directly change prenatal testing, eligibility for services, or any benefit.
  • The parent Act was not supplied, so I could not verify what duties or information requirements already exist under current law.

Money#

No publicly available information on the bill’s cost.

  • The Minister would have to arrange the information, consultations and required language versions, but the bill gives no cost estimate or staffing plan.
  • Health professionals would have a new duty to provide the information; any added time or administrative cost is not estimated.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not set a schedule or process for updating the information, or explain how the Minister would decide what counts as “up-to-date” and “evidence based.”
  • It does not set out how consultations would work or how the Minister would use them.
  • The text refers to community resources “developed and approved by the Ministry of the Minister.” It is unclear who is meant to develop and approve those resources.
  • The bill does not specify which additional languages the Minister should choose, or set timelines, oversight or reporting requirements.
  • The bill says it would generally start on Royal Assent, but the duty on health professionals would start six months later. It does not give a start date because that depends on Royal Assent.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to address the risk that expectant parents receive outdated, incorrect or biased information when told of a prenatal diagnosis.
  • Requiring information on outcomes and family resources could give parents a consistent written source, rather than leaving information entirely to each professional.
  • Consultation with people with expertise and organizations representing or advocating for people with Down syndrome could help shape the information and include perspectives beyond clinical facts.

Case against#

  • The bill does not explain how information will be checked, updated or reviewed over time. Without those details, it is unclear how the duty to provide up-to-date, evidence-based information would be maintained.
  • The required content is broad, and the bill does not set out how to ensure the information is balanced, useful to different families, or adapted to an individual parent’s needs.
  • The Minister’s choices about additional languages and the community resources to include are not guided by clear criteria in the bill.
  • The new duties could require time and resources from the Minister and health professionals, but the bill provides no estimate or funding plan.