New bill requires envelopes for fetal images

Summary#

Bill 259, the Viewer Discretion Act (Images of Fetuses), 2021, would create a new Ontario law; it does not amend an existing Act. Its stated aim is to regulate the mailing of images of fetuses.

  • Anyone distributing a graphic image of an aborted or otherwise non-viable fetus would have to use an opaque envelope, describe the contents on the outside, and clearly identify the sender.
  • The conditions apply to mailing and to “otherwise distribut[ing]” an image.
  • A person convicted of breaking the rule would be liable to a fine of $100 per image.

What it means for you#

  • People or organizations distributing these images: They would have to meet all three envelope and labelling conditions. The bill does not ban distributing the images.
  • People receiving them: The envelope would have to describe its contents and identify the sender.
  • General public: The bill does not directly change access to health care or create a new service.

Money#

No publicly available information.

  • The bill sets a fine of $100 per image for a person convicted of an offence. It does not say who would enforce the law or estimate enforcement costs.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not define “graphic image,” “otherwise non-viable,” or “otherwise distribute.”
  • It does not explain how the envelope requirements apply to distribution that does not involve mail or an envelope.
  • It does not name an enforcement body or set out procedures for investigating or prosecuting offences.
  • It does not say whether any defences or exceptions would apply.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that recipients would get a warning about the contents before seeing an image.
  • Requiring the sender to be identified could make it easier for recipients to know who sent the material.
  • The fine is set per image, so the penalty would reflect the number of images distributed.

Case against#

  • The bill does not define key terms, leaving uncertainty about what images and forms of distribution are covered.
  • Requiring an envelope even when an image is distributed another way may be difficult to apply; the bill does not explain how that would work.
  • The bill does not specify enforcement procedures or exceptions, which could leave important questions about how the prohibition would be applied.