Summary#
Bill 101, Harvey and Gurvir’s Law, would amend Ontario’s Regulated Health Professions Act, 1991. Its stated goal is to address misinformation and discrimination related to Down syndrome by ensuring that specified written information is available.
- The Minister must ensure that up-to-date, evidence-based written information about Down syndrome is available to regulated health professionals covered by the Act and to the public.
- The information must cover life expectancy; cognitive and physical development; education and psychosocial outcomes; and resources for families.
- It must also describe resources and supports from community organizations across Ontario. The bill’s wording about who develops and approves these resources is unclear.
- Before making the information available, the Minister must consult health professionals with particular expertise in Down syndrome and organizations representing or advocating for people with Down syndrome.
- The information must be available in English and French, and in any other languages the Minister considers appropriate.
- Starting six months after Royal Assent, a regulated health professional covered by the Act must provide the Minister’s written information when communicating a prenatal diagnosis of Down syndrome.
What it means for you#
- Expectant parents receiving a prenatal diagnosis: The health professional communicating the diagnosis must provide the Minister’s written information. The bill does not require a particular treatment, decision, or outcome.
- Regulated health professionals: They must provide that information when communicating a prenatal diagnosis. The bill does not specify further steps, such as a discussion to confirm that the information was understood.
- People with Down syndrome, families and the public: The Minister must make the specified information available, subject to the consultation and language requirements. The bill does not itself create new services or guarantee access to the community supports described.
- Government: The Minister must arrange for the information and required consultations. The bill amends an existing Act; it does not create a new agency.
Money#
No publicly available information on estimated costs.
- The bill requires the Minister to ensure the information is prepared and made available, and to arrange consultations and translations. It gives no cost estimate or funding source.
- The bill does not set fees, fines or payments to families or community organizations.
What is unclear#
- The supplied material does not include the current Regulated Health Professions Act, 1991, so existing duties, definitions and enforcement rules cannot be checked against the bill.
- The bill does not define “up-to-date” or “evidence based,” or set a schedule for reviewing and updating the information.
- It does not specify how the information’s accuracy or use will be monitored, or what happens if a professional does not provide it.
- It is unclear exactly what the bill means by community-organization resources and supports being “developed and approved by the Ministry of the Minister.”
- The bill does not state its status or whether it has become law.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to address the risk that families receive outdated, incorrect or biased information when they receive a prenatal diagnosis.
- Requiring written information on outcomes and family resources could give parents a shared source of information, rather than leaving its provision entirely to individual practice.
- Consultation with experts and organizations representing or advocating for people with Down syndrome could help shape the information.
- Requiring information in English and French, and allowing other languages, could make it available to more people.
Case against#
- The bill does not set standards for what counts as current, evidence-based information or how often it must be updated. This could leave important decisions about content to the Minister.
- It requires a written handout but does not specify whether parents must also receive individualized discussion or help finding the listed supports.
- The required consultation does not specify how participants are chosen or how their input affects the final information.
- The bill creates duties and translation work but provides no cost estimate or funding details.