Summary#
Bill 227, the Public Health Accountability Act (In Honour of Dr. Sheela Basrur), 2020, would amend Ontario’s Health Protection and Promotion Act. It would make the Chief Medical Officer of Health (CMOH) an officer of the Legislative Assembly and change how the CMOH is appointed, removed or replaced temporarily. Its stated goal is public health accountability.
- The Assembly would appoint the CMOH for five years, with one possible five-year reappointment. A panel with representatives of recognized parties, chaired by the Speaker, must agree unanimously on the candidate unless the Assembly itself decides unanimously to use a different process.
- The Assembly could remove or suspend the CMOH for cause by a two-thirds vote. When the Assembly is not in session, the Board of Internal Economy could suspend the CMOH for cause by unanimous agreement.
- If the CMOH cannot perform the job or the office is vacant, the Assembly could appoint a temporary CMOH. When the Assembly is not in session, the Board of Internal Economy could do so. The temporary CMOH would have the CMOH’s powers and duties.
- In a qualifying public-health-related emergency, the Assembly must appoint a select committee as soon as reasonably possible. Its role would be to receive advice from, and give advice to, the CMOH.
- The bill would repeal section 86.3 and change section 86.4 of the Act. The supplied materials do not explain what those changes would remove or alter.
What it means for you#
- For the public: The bill changes how the CMOH’s office is appointed and overseen. It does not set new patient benefits, taxes or fees, or create a new front-line health service.
- For the CMOH: The Board of Internal Economy would set salary and benefits. The CMOH would be a member of the Public Service Pension Plan by default, but could opt out within 60 days of appointment; that choice would be irrevocable. The CMOH would also need approval to hold other work or office, with an exception for other Assembly- or Board-appointed offices.
- For the Associate Chief Medical Officer of Health: The CMOH would specify that officer’s functions and duties in writing.
- For the Assembly and Board of Internal Economy: They would take on appointment, temporary appointment, compensation, and certain suspension decisions. The Board would also decide whether to approve expense reimbursements.
- For the emergency committee: Its stated role is to exchange advice with the CMOH; the bill does not give it an express power to direct the CMOH.
Money#
The bill requires compensation and allows expense reimbursements, but no cost estimate is provided.
- The Board of Internal Economy must set the CMOH’s salary and benefits and set compensation for a temporary CMOH.
- The CMOH and temporary CMOH may be reimbursed for reasonable expenses, subject to Board approval.
- No publicly available information on the expected total cost, pension cost, or staffing needs is included in the supplied material.
What is unclear#
- The parent Act was not supplied, so the changes cannot be fully compared with current law. In particular, the effects of repealing section 86.3 and changing section 86.4 cannot be verified.
- The bill does not define “cause,” or set out a process for deciding whether cause exists.
- The appointment panel must agree unanimously, but the bill does not explain how an appointment would proceed if it cannot agree and the Assembly does not unanimously choose another route.
- The bill does not set out the emergency committee’s size, how it would work, or how its advice would be handled.
- The bill does not include a cost estimate or explain how any new administrative work would be staffed.
Case for#
- A fixed term and removal only for cause could give the CMOH protection from being removed without a stated reason.
- Requiring broad agreement on appointments could support confidence in the choice across parties.
- Temporary appointments could help maintain the office’s functions when the CMOH is unable to serve or the position is vacant.
- A committee required during certain emergencies could provide a formal way for the Assembly and CMOH to exchange advice.
Case against#
- The unanimous panel requirement could delay an appointment if members cannot agree; the bill gives no clear fallback unless the Assembly also agrees unanimously to another process.
- The bill does not define “cause” or explain how suspension and removal decisions would be assessed.
- The emergency committee’s role is limited to advice, and the bill does not explain what happens if its advice and the CMOH’s position differ.
- Salary, benefits, expenses and temporary appointments could add public costs, but the bill gives no estimate.