Ombudsman becomes Assembly officer

Summary#

Bill 22, the Making the Patient Ombudsman an Officer of the Assembly Act, 2021, amends Ontario’s Excellent Care for All Act, 2010. It changes who appoints, pays and can remove the patient ombudsman, and where the ombudsman reports. Its stated aim is to make the patient ombudsman an officer of the Assembly.

  • The Assembly would appoint the patient ombudsman by order. Under the current arrangement described in the explanatory note, the Lieutenant Governor in Council appoints the ombudsman.
  • The Board of Internal Economy would set the ombudsman’s salary, benefits and related rights, replacing the Lieutenant Governor in Council’s role in setting remuneration.
  • The Assembly could remove the ombudsman for cause, but only by a vote of at least two-thirds of its members.
  • The Assembly could appoint a temporary ombudsman for up to six months. If the Assembly is not in session, the Board of Internal Economy could make that temporary appointment.
  • The ombudsman would report at least annually to the Speaker, who must arrange for the report to be presented to the Assembly during a session or at its next session.

What it means for you#

  • Patients: The bill changes the ombudsman’s place in government. The supplied text does not directly change patient complaint rights or services.
  • Patient ombudsman: The current ombudsman would stay in office until their appointment is revoked under the new rule or their term ends.
  • Assembly and its Board of Internal Economy: The Assembly would appoint the ombudsman and could remove them for cause with a two-thirds vote. The Board would set their pay and benefits, and could appoint a temporary replacement when the Assembly is not in session.
  • Public: Reports would go to the Speaker and be presented to the Assembly. The bill does not require reports more often than annually, though the ombudsman may report at other times.
  • General public: The bill does not itself set up a new patient service or change how complaints are handled. The parent Act was not supplied, so I could not verify whether other parts of the existing law affect those matters.

Money#

No publicly available information on the bill’s estimated cost.

  • The Board of Internal Economy must set the ombudsman’s salary, benefits and related rights, but the bill gives no amounts.
  • The bill allows temporary appointments of up to six months but gives no cost estimate or staffing details.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not define “for cause” in the supplied text. The parent Act was not supplied, so it is not possible to check whether it defines the term.
  • The bill does not set out qualifications or a selection process for regular or temporary appointments.
  • It does not specify how the Assembly or the Board would decide that the ombudsman is unable or unwilling to perform the duties.
  • The bill changes reporting arrangements, but the supplied text does not explain how reports would be handled if the Assembly is not in session beyond presentation at its next session.

Case for#

  • The bill moves appointment and reporting away from the provincial executive and into the Legislature. That could give the ombudsman a more direct line of accountability to the Assembly.
  • Requiring a two-thirds vote and cause for removal may protect the ombudsman from being removed by a simple majority without a stated reason.
  • Requiring reports to be presented to the Assembly could make the ombudsman’s activities and recommendations more visible to legislators.

Case against#

  • The bill does not explain what counts as “cause” or set out a process for deciding whether cause exists. That could leave an important limit on removal unclear.
  • The bill does not set out appointment criteria or a selection process, including for temporary appointments.
  • A possible trade-off is that the Assembly’s role could make appointments more dependent on political agreement; the bill does not explain how disagreements would be resolved.
  • The Board of Internal Economy would set the ombudsman’s pay and benefits, but the bill gives no limits or process for those decisions.