Public Health Chief to Have Fixed Term

Summary#

Bill 52, the Public Health Accountability Act (In Honour of Dr. Sheela Basrur), 2022, would amend Ontario’s Health Protection and Promotion Act. It would change how the existing Chief Medical Officer of Health (CMOH) is appointed, serves and can be removed, and require a legislative committee during certain declared emergencies. The title presents public-health accountability as the bill’s goal.

  • The Legislative Assembly would appoint the CMOH for five years, with one possible five-year reappointment. Normally, a selection panel must agree unanimously on the person; the Assembly can instead decide unanimously to bypass that panel process.
  • The Assembly could remove or suspend the CMOH for cause (a reason sufficient under the law) by a two-thirds vote. When the Assembly is not in session, the Board of Internal Economy could unanimously suspend the CMOH for cause, subject to time limits and later Assembly action.
  • The Board of Internal Economy would set the CMOH’s salary and benefits. The CMOH would normally join the Public Service Pension Plan, but could opt out within 60 days.
  • If the CMOH cannot do the job or the office is vacant, a temporary CMOH could be appointed. That person would have the CMOH’s powers and duties; the Assembly appoints them, or the Board may do so while the Assembly is not in session.
  • After a qualifying emergency declaration, the Assembly would have to appoint a select committee as soon as reasonably possible. The committee would receive advice from, and provide advice to, the CMOH about the emergency situation.

What it means for you#

  • For the public: The bill does not create a new public service, benefit, or general public right. Its main changes concern the CMOH’s appointment and the Assembly’s role during certain emergencies.
  • For the CMOH: The officeholder would have a fixed term and new rules for appointment, removal, salary, benefits, pension participation and other work. The CMOH could not be an Assembly member or hold other employment or office without prior approval, subject to an exception for multiple offices appointed by the Assembly or Board.
  • For the Associate CMOH: Their functions and duties would be those the CMOH specifies in writing.
  • For the Assembly and Board of Internal Economy: They would have new appointment, suspension and pay-setting duties. A qualifying emergency would trigger a duty to appoint a select committee with equal numbers of members from recognized parties.
  • For the committee: Its role would be to exchange advice with the CMOH, not to direct the CMOH or manage the emergency. It would end three months after the emergency declaration ends, unless another qualifying emergency is declared first.

Money#

No publicly available information on the bill’s estimated cost.

  • The Board would set the CMOH’s salary and benefits, and could approve reimbursement of reasonable expenses. The bill gives no amounts.
  • A temporary CMOH would also receive salary and benefits set by the Board, and could receive approved expense reimbursement.
  • The bill does not state the cost of the select committee or give a staffing or funding estimate.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied materials do not include the full current Health Protection and Promotion Act. I could not verify how the bill’s changes compare with current appointment, removal, or other rules, or what the repealed and altered provisions do in context.
  • “For cause” is not defined in the bill text supplied. It is unclear what reasons would qualify.
  • The bill does not set out detailed steps or deadlines for the selection panel, beyond requiring unanimous agreement unless the Assembly unanimously chooses otherwise.
  • It does not explain how the select committee would conduct its work, or require it to publish advice or report to the public.
  • The bill does not explain how independent Assembly members would be represented on the emergency committee; its composition rule specifies equal numbers from recognized parties.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that fixed terms and a high vote threshold for removal could protect the CMOH from being removed for ordinary political disagreement.
  • Requiring a cross-party panel to agree on a candidate could encourage broad support for the appointment, while leaving the Assembly a unanimous way to use a different process.
  • A temporary CMOH could fill the role if the officeholder cannot serve or the office becomes vacant.
  • A required committee during qualifying emergencies could give the Assembly a formal way to exchange advice with the CMOH.

Case against#

  • Unanimity requirements for selecting a CMOH or temporary CMOH could make agreement difficult. The bill does not explain what happens if the panel cannot agree.
  • The bill gives the emergency committee an advisory role but does not set out how its advice would be handled or require public reporting.
  • The bill does not define “for cause” in the supplied text, leaving an important limit on suspension and removal unclear.
  • The bill assigns salary, benefits and expense decisions to the Board but provides no cost estimate or detailed process for those decisions.