Summary#
Bill 95, the Making the Patient Ombudsman an Officer of the Assembly Act, 2023, would amend Ontario’s Excellent Care for All Act, 2010. Its stated goal is to make the patient ombudsman an officer of the Legislative Assembly and change who appoints, pays and receives reports from that office.
- The Assembly would appoint the patient ombudsman by order.
- The Board of Internal Economy would set the ombudsman’s salary, benefits and related rights, including severance and retirement benefits.
- The Assembly could revoke the appointment for cause, but only by a vote of at least two-thirds of its members.
- The Assembly could appoint a temporary ombudsman for up to six months if the position is vacant or the ombudsman cannot or will not perform the duties. If the Assembly is not in session, the Board of Internal Economy may make that temporary appointment.
- The ombudsman would report to the Speaker at least annually, and at other times the ombudsman considers appropriate. The Speaker would have to table the report in the Assembly during a session or at its next session.
- The current ombudsman would stay in office until the appointment is revoked under the new rule or the term expires.
What it means for you#
- Patients and the public: The bill does not directly change how patients make complaints, what the ombudsman can investigate, or what help patients can receive.
- Patient Ombudsman: The office would report to the Speaker rather than the Minister. The bill changes who appoints and sets compensation for the ombudsman, but does not set out a new complaint-handling process.
- Legislative Assembly and Board of Internal Economy: The Assembly would appoint the ombudsman and could revoke the appointment under the two-thirds vote and “for cause” rules. The Board would set compensation and could appoint a temporary ombudsman while the Assembly is not in session.
Money#
No publicly available information on the bill’s cost.
- The Board of Internal Economy would set the ombudsman’s salary and benefits, including severance and retirement-related rights.
- The bill gives no estimate for compensation, temporary appointments or other costs, and does not set out a spending amount.
What is unclear#
- The bill does not define “for cause.”
- It does not state how candidates for the permanent appointment would be selected or what qualifications they must have.
- It does not specify how temporary appointees would be selected.
- No publicly available information on whether the changed reporting arrangements would affect the ombudsman’s existing work or resources.
Case for#
- The change could place the ombudsman at a greater distance from the government ministry responsible for health, since the Assembly would appoint the ombudsman and receive reports. That may support the office’s independence, though the bill does not guarantee a particular result.
- Requiring a two-thirds Assembly vote to revoke the appointment for cause could make removal less vulnerable to a narrow majority’s decision.
- The temporary appointment rules could allow the office to be filled for a limited time when the ombudsman cannot serve or the position is vacant.
Case against#
- The bill does not explain what “for cause” means or set out how the Assembly would assess it, leaving an important removal rule undefined.
- The bill does not provide selection criteria or a process for choosing the permanent ombudsman, so those details would be left to arrangements outside the bill.
- A two-thirds vote may protect the ombudsman from removal by a simple majority, but it could also make removal harder when the Assembly is divided.