Law would ban non-medical cat declawing

Summary#

Bill 240, Teddy’s Law (Anti-Declawing), 2020, would amend Ontario’s Provincial Animal Welfare Services Act, 2019 by adding a rule about declawing cats. Its stated goal is to prohibit non-essential cat declawing.

  • The bill would prohibit anyone from permitting, causing, encouraging, promoting, arranging, conducting, assisting in, benefiting from, or taking part in a cat’s partial digital amputation unless a veterinarian—or someone working under that veterinarian’s supervision—determines it would not be medically unnecessary.
  • The bill defines partial digital amputation as surgically removing the third phalanx (bone) of each digit on a cat’s front paws, or front and rear paws.
  • It defines medically unnecessary surgery as surgery that is not required or is not in the animal’s overall best interest.
  • The bill would add a breach of this rule to a list in the Act. The parent Act was not supplied, so the effect of that list entry cannot be verified here.
  • The rule would start when the bill receives Royal Assent.

What it means for you#

  • Cat owners and other people involved: You could not permit, arrange, assist in, or otherwise take part in the covered surgery unless the required determination has been made. The bill does not ban every such surgery.
  • Veterinarians and supervised workers: A veterinarian providing care under the standards set under the Veterinarians Act, or someone working under that veterinarian’s supervision, would have to make the determination for the exception to apply.
  • People who do not own cats: The prohibition also covers people who encourage, promote, conduct, or receive a financial or material benefit from the procedure.
  • The bill does not directly set rules for other veterinary procedures or animal welfare matters.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill does not state a budget, staffing requirement, fee, or cost estimate.
  • It does not state a penalty in the text provided. The amended list in the parent Act may affect consequences, but that cannot be verified without the Act.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not explain how a veterinarian should assess whether surgery is required and in the animal’s overall best interest, or what records must be kept.
  • It does not set an application, review, appeal, or reporting process.
  • The parent Act was not supplied, so the current rules, enforcement process, and consequences of a breach cannot be verified against the law being amended.
  • The bill does not explain how the rule would be monitored or enforced in practice.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to prevent cat declawing that is not medically justified, while leaving an exception for surgery determined not to be medically unnecessary.
  • A possible argument for the approach is that it gives a veterinarian responsible for the cat’s care a role in deciding whether the exception applies.
  • The prohibition reaches not only the person conducting the surgery, but also people who arrange, assist in, promote, or benefit from it.

Case against#

  • One concern is that “overall best interest” is not defined further, leaving important judgment to the veterinarian or supervised person making the determination.
  • The bill does not set out documentation, review, or appeal rules for that determination.
  • It is unclear what enforcement powers or penalties would apply, because the parent Act was not supplied.