Summary#
Bill 242, the Caregiver and Homeworker Protection Act, 2020, would create a new stand-alone Act. It would require the Minister of Labour, Training and Skills Development to establish and maintain an online registry of certain employers who receive notices of contravention under the Employment Standards Act, 2000. Its stated goal is to protect caregivers and homeworkers.
- The registry must list employers who receive a notice under section 113(1) of the Employment Standards Act, 2000 in relation to a caregiver or homeworker.
- The registry would not include notices relating to a regulated health professional or public sector employee, or notices in a setting regulated by the Ministry of Health.
- If an employer applies to the Ontario Labour Relations Board for a review and the Board finds no contravention, the employer’s name must be removed as soon as practicable.
- The Act would deem disclosures of personal information made to comply with it to comply with a specified provision of the Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Act.
- The bill defines caregivers and homeworkers by specified National Occupational Classification codes and work in a private residence. Caregivers do not include child care providers as defined in the Child Care and Early Years Act, 2014.
What it means for you#
- Caregivers and homeworkers covered by the definitions: You could see an employer’s name on a public Ontario website after the employer receives a qualifying notice. The bill does not require the registry to publish workers’ names or details of the notice.
- Employers: A qualifying notice could lead to your name being published. The bill does not require a Board review before listing. If you apply for review and the Board finds no contravention, your name must be removed as soon as practicable.
- Minister and ministry: The minister must establish and maintain the registry and publish it on a Government of Ontario website.
- Other workers and employers: The registry rule excludes notices relating to regulated health professionals or public sector employees, and notices in settings regulated by the Ministry of Health. The bill does not itself change employment standards or create a new fine or benefit.
Money#
No publicly available information on the cost is included in the supplied material.
- The minister must establish and maintain the registry, but the bill gives no estimate for staff, website, or other costs.
What is unclear#
- The bill does not say what information besides employers’ names the registry may show, or how long names stay listed if there is no successful review.
- It does not explain how quickly names must be added or how the registry will be checked for accuracy.
- The bill does not define “any setting regulated by the Ministry of Health.”
- The definitions rely on National Occupational Classification codes that may be amended over time; the bill does not explain how a code change would affect who is covered.
- The bill does not set out how employers apply for Board review, or what happens to a listing while a review is pending.
Case for#
- A public list could make information about employers who receive these notices easier to find.
- The registry could give workers and the public a way to identify employers named in notices related to caregivers or homeworkers.
- Removing an employer’s name after the Board finds no contravention could reduce the risk of keeping a name listed after that finding.
Case against#
- An employer may be listed based on a notice before the Board has found that a contravention occurred. A public listing could be mistaken for a final finding.
- The bill does not say how the registry will explain what a notice alleges or show whether a review is underway.
- Employers must apply for review to trigger removal under the bill; it does not provide for automatic removal after a Board finding unless the employer applied.
- The bill does not provide cost estimates or explain how the ministry will maintain the registry.