Summary#
Bill 80, the Archives and Recordkeeping Amendment Act, 2019, would amend Ontario’s Archives and Recordkeeping Act, 2006. Its stated goal is to impose a penalty for certain conduct involving public records of archival value.
- A person would commit an offence if they contravene subsection 15(1) of the existing Act with the intent to deprive a public body, the Archives of Ontario or the Archivist of custody, control, use of, or access to a public record of archival value.
- On conviction, the person could be fined up to $50,000.
- The change would take effect on Royal Assent. The supplied material does not establish whether the bill received Royal Assent.
What it means for you#
- Individuals: If you contravene subsection 15(1) with the specified intent, you could face a fine of up to $50,000 if convicted. The bill does not create an offence for every contravention of subsection 15(1); the stated intent must also be present.
- Public bodies, the Archives of Ontario and the Archivist: The offence would apply to conduct intended to deprive them of custody, control, use of, or access to a public record of archival value.
- Public generally: The bill does not itself set out a process for accessing records or guarantee access to a record.
- The parent Act was not supplied, so I could not verify what subsection 15(1) currently requires or how this offence would interact with the rest of the Act.
Money#
No cost information is in the available material.
- The bill sets a maximum fine of $50,000, but gives no estimate of how many fines might be imposed or how much revenue they might produce.
- No information is provided about enforcement or administration costs.
What is unclear#
- What conduct subsection 15(1) prohibits or requires; the parent Act was not provided.
- Whether the parent Act defines “public record of archival value”; the supplied bill does not define the term.
- Who would investigate or prosecute the offence, and what process would be used to establish intent.
- Whether any rules, guidance, or reporting would accompany the offence.
Case for#
- A possible argument for the bill is that a fine could deter intentional conduct that deprives public bodies, the Archives of Ontario or the Archivist of control over or access to records of archival value.
- The offence is limited to a person who both contravenes subsection 15(1) and acts with the specified intent. That makes it narrower than an offence based on any contravention alone.
- The maximum fine makes the potential penalty clear in the bill.
Case against#
- The bill relies on subsection 15(1), but that provision is not included in the supplied material. Readers therefore cannot assess from this text alone what conduct could lead to the offence.
- The bill does not explain how intent would be investigated or proved, or identify the body responsible for enforcement.
- It sets a maximum fine of $50,000 but provides no information about how penalties would be applied in practice.