Summary#
Bill 246, the Safer School Buses Act, 2021, amends Ontario’s Highway Traffic Act. It took effect on July 1, 2022. Its title points to safer school buses as its aim, but the materials do not promise a specific safety result.
- An Ontario-registered school bus made on or after January 1, 2005 must have four overhead amber lights and four overhead red lights: one of each on each side at the front and rear.
- For buses made on or after that date, the rear sign must say “do not pass when red lights flashing.” Earlier buses use “do not pass when signals flashing.” Yellow buses operating under a permit also have to display the required school-bus signs.
- A motor vehicle that is not a school bus must not display the listed school-bus warning words or have a school-bus stop arm.
- The rules governing school-bus signal lights are amended by removing references to “red” in specified provisions.
- The bill adds power to make regulations about equipment on or in certain vehicles, including requiring equipment and setting its standards. The bill itself does not set those standards.
What it means for you#
- Ontario-registered school buses made on or after January 1, 2005: The bus must have the specified overhead amber and red lights. The bill does not name who must arrange or pay for the equipment.
- Buses operating under a permit and painted partly or entirely chrome yellow: They must display the specified school-bus words and the rear warning sign that matches the bus’s manufacturing date.
- Drivers and other vehicle owners: A vehicle that is not a school bus must not display the listed warning words or have a school-bus stop arm.
- The public: The bill changes bus equipment and sign rules. It does not create a new service, benefit, tax, or fee in the supplied text.
Money#
No cost information is in the available material.
- The required lights may involve costs for buses covered by the rule, but no estimate or payment arrangement is provided.
- The bill allows future regulations to require equipment or set equipment standards. It gives no estimate of any costs those regulations could create.
What is unclear#
- The bill does not set technical standards for the lights or say who must pay for them.
- It does not show the full amended rules for when the amber and red lights operate. The supplied material says those rules are amended, but does not establish the full operating sequence.
- The bill does not explain whether the new equipment requirements overlap with other existing requirements.
- The supplied material does not include the parent Act, so the full previous rules and the exact before-and-after effect of every amendment could not be verified.
Case for#
- A possible argument for the bill is that requiring both amber and red lights on covered buses could give road users clearer warning signals.
- The matching rear-sign rules distinguish buses made before 2005 from newer buses, which the bill treats differently.
- The added regulation-making power could allow equipment requirements and standards to be set in regulations.
Case against#
- One concern is that the bill requires specified equipment on buses made from 2005 onward without stating the cost or who pays.
- The bill leaves equipment standards and any further requirements to regulations, so the full obligations are not all set out in the bill.
- The supplied text does not show the complete operating rules for the lights, making it hard to assess how the amended rules will work in practice.