Bill to identify adults at risk of abuse

Summary#

Bill 253, the Support for Adults in Need of Assistance Act, 2021, would create a new Ontario law. Its goal is to identify people aged 16 or older who may be abused or neglected and recommend support for them.

  • Regulated health professionals would have to report reasonable suspicions directly to a board of health, including further suspicions about someone they have reported before.
  • Boards of health would have to assess and verify each report within 48, 72 or 120 hours, depending on the reported urgency. The bill also applies certain entry powers from the Health Protection and Promotion Act.
  • Each board would have to establish a review team, including at least one legally qualified medical practitioner. For verified information, the team would review the case and recommend a support and assistance plan to the board.
  • The bill would allow relevant information to be disclosed to review teams despite confidentiality or privilege, except solicitor-client privilege.
  • Boards would have to publish numbers, general reasons and outcomes of reports every six months, without personal information.

What it means for you#

  • Regulated health professionals: You would have to report directly to a board of health as soon as you had a reasonable suspicion of abuse or neglect. Failing to report could bring a fine of up to $5,000 if the information came to you through professional or official duties. The bill protects good-faith reporters from legal action, unless they act maliciously or without reasonable grounds.
  • Adults aged 16 or older: A report could lead to an assessment and, if the information is verified, a review and a recommended support plan. The bill does not say you must accept support, or give you a right to receive it.
  • Boards of health and their staff: Boards would have to meet the assessment deadlines, establish review teams and publish the required information. Staff and review-team chairs would have reporting duties to the medical officer of health.
  • Adults who may be incapable, and their representatives: If the team has reason to believe an adult may be incapable, the plan must include consultation with any substitute decision-maker. If necessary to assist the adult, it must also include consultation with the Public Guardian and Trustee about assessing capacity or applying to court for a guardian.
  • People who report or provide information: The bill permits disclosure of information reasonably needed for a review, even if it may otherwise be confidential or privileged. It does not remove solicitor-client privilege.
  • People aged 16 or 17: The bill says it does not affect existing child-protection reporting duties under the Child, Youth and Family Services Act, 2017.

Money#

No publicly available information on the bill’s cost.

  • Boards would have to provide staff for assessments and establish review teams, but the bill gives no staffing numbers, funding source or cost estimate.
  • The bill sets fines of up to $5,000 for failing to report in the specified circumstances and for obstructing certain entry powers.

What is unclear#

  • “Reasonable suspicion,” “abused or neglected,” and the categories used to set assessment deadlines are not defined in the bill.
  • The bill does not set rules for how boards assess reports, how teams make recommendations, or whether and how boards must act on those recommendations.
  • It does not say what services or funding would be available, or how an adult’s wishes would shape a plan.
  • The bill applies entry powers from the Health Protection and Promotion Act. That Act was not supplied, so the exact scope and limits of those powers could not be verified.
  • The bill does not explain how this process would coordinate with existing services or programs.
  • The bill says it would come into force one year after Royal Assent; the supplied material does not establish whether or when it would receive Royal Assent.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to create a way to identify and respond to suspected abuse or neglect of people aged 16 or older.
  • Requiring direct, repeat reporting could help boards receive information that might otherwise not reach them.
  • Deadlines for assessment and verification could make boards respond within a set time, with shorter deadlines for reports suggesting more urgent need.
  • Review teams with medical expertise could bring more than one perspective to a case before recommending support.
  • Publishing regular, non-personal information could help the public see how many reports are made and what outcomes follow.

Case against#

  • The reporting duty is broad: it applies to reasonable suspicions, and the bill does not define abuse, neglect or reasonable suspicion.
  • The bill permits disclosure despite confidentiality protections and gives boards certain entry powers, but the supplied text does not fully explain the limits or safeguards for those powers.
  • The bill requires recommendations, but does not require boards to provide the recommended assistance or say what help would be available.
  • The bill adds duties for health professionals and boards without giving a cost estimate or funding plan.
  • It is unclear how the process would protect an adult’s choice and privacy during assessment and review, beyond the limits on publishing personal information.