Health professionals report dangerous driving after warnings

Summary#

Bill 105, the Assessing Fitness to Drive Act, 2023, would amend Ontario’s Highway Traffic Act; it would not create a separate law or agency. Its stated change is to require reports about a patient’s fitness to drive only when the patient has been warned of a dangerous medical condition and continues to drive. The bill’s stated goal is not set out separately.

  • It would require legally qualified and registered psychologists, optometrists, medical practitioners and nurse practitioners to report a patient aged 16 or older if they believe the patient has a medical condition that makes driving dangerous and the patient continues to drive after being warned.
  • The report must give the patient’s name, address and medical condition to the Registrar.
  • The explanatory note describes current section 203 as requiring reports about prescribed conditions, and allowing reports about other conditions or impairments that may make driving dangerous. The bill would replace that approach. I could not verify the current law against the Highway Traffic Act, which was not supplied.
  • The bill also changes two parts of section 204, including repealing one subsection. Without the text of that section, their effects cannot be verified.
  • The bill says it would come into force on Royal Assent.

What it means for you#

  • Health professionals named in the bill: They would have a duty to report when all three conditions are met: the patient is at least 16, the professional believes a medical condition makes driving dangerous, and the patient continues driving after being warned.
  • Patients and drivers: A medical condition alone would not trigger this new reporting duty under section 203. The bill does not itself set out a licence suspension or penalty for the patient.
  • The Registrar: Would receive reports containing the patient’s name, address and medical condition. The bill does not say what action the Registrar must take after receiving a report.
  • Other people: The bill does not directly change driving eligibility rules for everyone or create a new service for assessing drivers.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill creates a reporting duty, but gives no estimate of the costs of handling reports or any added workload for health professionals or the Registrar.
  • It does not specify new funding, fees, fines or savings.

What is unclear#

  • “Medical condition” is not defined in the bill. It does not say whether or how functional or visual impairments fit within that term.
  • The bill does not specify what counts as warning a patient, or whether the warning must be written or recorded.
  • It does not explain what the Registrar must do with a report, how quickly, or what review or appeal rights apply.
  • The effects of the changes to section 204 cannot be determined without that section’s text.
  • The bill does not explain how the new reporting rule would interact with other reporting duties or processes.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to limit mandatory reports to cases where a professional believes driving is dangerous and the patient keeps driving after a warning.
  • A possible argument for this approach is that it keeps a reporting duty for serious safety concerns while giving the patient notice of the concern first.
  • Requiring reports from the named health professionals could give the Registrar information about patients who continue driving despite a warning.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the bill makes a warning and continued driving prerequisites for a mandatory report. It does not require a report under section 203 if a professional believes driving is dangerous but the patient has not yet been warned.
  • The bill does not define “medical condition” or explain how professionals should assess whether it makes driving dangerous. That could leave key decisions unclear.
  • The bill requires disclosure of a patient’s name, address and medical condition but does not set out safeguards or explain what happens to the information.
  • Because the effects of the section 204 changes are unclear from the supplied material, their impact on reporting or related duties cannot be assessed.