Land-use bill creates fallow land rights

Summary#

Bill 28, the Alternate Land Use and Services Program for Agricultural Land Act, 2018, would create a new Ontario law; it does not amend an existing Act. Its stated goal is to support voluntary uses of agricultural land that establish, restore or preserve natural ecosystems, or produce ecosystem services.

  • It recognizes an agricultural landowner’s right to set aside any part of the land as fallow for those purposes.
  • The Minister of Natural Resources and Forestry must develop and administer a provincial framework and action plan within 12 months of Royal Assent.
  • The framework must include guidelines, standardized public education materials, promotion of research and international symposia, and programs for government funding—using money appropriated to the Ministry and to the extent the Minister considers appropriate.
  • The framework must also encourage non-government fundraising. The Minister may update it and may consult other ministries, the federal government or other people and organizations.
  • The Minister must publish the framework and any updates on an Ontario government website within one month. The Act would start on Royal Assent.

What it means for you#

  • Agricultural landowners: The bill recognizes a right to set aside any part of their land for the stated ecological purposes. It does not require owners to participate, and it does not create a direct payment entitlement.
  • The minister and Ontario government: The minister must create and administer the framework. The framework must provide for standardized educational materials to be created and distributed to the public.
  • Researchers and the public: The framework must promote research and international symposia. The bill does not require any particular research project or event to take place.
  • People who might seek funding: The bill requires the framework to include government-funding programs, but any funding is limited to money appropriated to the Ministry and to the extent the Minister considers appropriate. It does not set application or eligibility rules.
  • General public: The bill does not directly change taxes, farming rules, or access to private land.

Money#

No cost estimate is included in the available material.

  • The framework must include programs for government funding, but the bill does not set an amount. Funding is subject to money appropriated to the Ministry and the Minister’s judgment about how much is appropriate.
  • The bill also calls for encouraging money to be raised from non-government sources. No amount or fundraising method is specified.
  • The bill requires ministerial work and publication, but the cost of that work is not stated. No publicly available information.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not define “agricultural land” or “fallow.”
  • It does not set detailed rules for who could receive funding, how to apply, how decisions would be made, or whether there would be reviews or appeals.
  • The bill does not say how much funding would be available or how the government would oversee funded projects.
  • The Minister may consult others, but consultation is not required. The bill does not specify how landowners, Indigenous communities or other affected groups would be involved.
  • It is unclear how the recognized right would work alongside other rules that apply to agricultural land.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that it gives landowners legal recognition for setting aside land for ecological purposes, while keeping participation voluntary.
  • The framework could give landowners guidance and the public standardized educational materials.
  • Promoting research and international symposia could help share information about these land uses.
  • Government and non-government funding could support projects, while the bill leaves the amount of government support subject to appropriations and ministerial judgment.

Case against#

  • The bill does not guarantee funding or require any specific project to be supported, so the practical value of the program could depend on later decisions.
  • It leaves important matters—such as funding eligibility, application rules and oversight—to the framework or later decisions.
  • The bill does not require the Minister to consult affected groups, even though the framework could shape how the program works.
  • The right is recognized in broad terms, but the bill does not explain how it interacts with other rules applying to agricultural land.