Conservation Plan Tightens Land-Use Across Area

Summary#

Bill 71, the Paris Galt Moraine Conservation Act, 2019, would create a new Act and make related amendments to five other Acts. It would let the Lieutenant Governor in Council designate the Paris Galt Moraine Area and let the Minister of Municipal Affairs and Housing establish a conservation plan for it. The stated goal is to protect the area’s ecological and water-related functions; the bill does not guarantee that result.

  • The plan could designate land-use areas, prohibit or restrict land uses and buildings, and set policies for land, resources and water.
  • Decisions under planning and other listed laws would have to conform to the plan. The plan would prevail over conflicting official plans, zoning by-laws and provincial planning policy statements.
  • Municipalities and municipal planning authorities covered by regulations would have to amend official plans and zoning by-laws within 18 months after the plan is filed. The Minister could step in to amend them if a municipality does not comply.
  • People or corporations who breach a plan prohibition or restriction could face daily fines. A court could also order steps to address harm and prevent further offences.
  • The bill includes exceptions for certain lawful existing uses, previously authorized projects and other cases, subject to the conditions in the bill.

What it means for you#

  • People who own or use land in the designated area: If a plan is made, it could limit what land can be used for and where buildings can be built. Some existing lawful uses and previously authorized projects are exempt, but the exceptions have conditions.
  • Municipalities and municipal planning authorities: Those covered by regulations would have to change planning documents to conform with the plan. If they do not, the Minister could exercise their planning powers after giving at least 30 days’ written notice, or make certain amendments that cannot be appealed.
  • Businesses and individuals: Breaking a plan prohibition or restriction could lead to a fine of up to $25,000 per day for an individual or $50,000 per day for a corporation on a first conviction. Higher daily maximums apply for later convictions. Directors, officers, employees or agents may also be guilty if they meet the conditions in the bill.
  • First Nations and the public: The Minister must consult affected or potentially affected First Nations and provide public participation during the plan’s 10-year reviews. The bill does not set those consultation requirements for establishing the initial plan.
  • General public: The bill does not directly create a public benefit, service, tax or general ban. Its practical effects would depend on whether the area is designated and what the plan says.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill gives no estimate for government, municipal, business or household costs, and does not set out an appropriation.
  • The Minister or a municipality may make agreements that share the costs of carrying out parts of the plan.
  • Regulations could set fees for applications to amend the plan. An applicant may also be required to pay the cost of giving notice about an amendment application.
  • Fines are authorized, but the material does not estimate how many would be imposed or how much revenue they might raise.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not itself designate the area or establish the plan. The boundaries, land-use rules and any natural core or linkage areas would depend on later regulations.
  • The bill does not set out the process for creating the initial plan, including public consultation, timelines or appeal rights.
  • The plan’s specific restrictions, and how the bill’s objectives would be applied to individual decisions, are not known from this text.
  • The bill does not say how many municipalities or planning authorities would be prescribed, or what staffing and enforcement resources would be needed.
  • Current law and the effect of the proposed changes on existing rules could not be verified because the Acts being amended were not supplied.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to protect water, ecological functions and connected natural land through a plan that can guide development decisions across municipal boundaries.
  • Requiring planning decisions to conform to one plan could reduce conflicts between municipal planning rules and the conservation goals for the area.
  • The bill requires review every 10 years, with public participation and consultation with affected or potentially affected First Nations. It also prevents reviews from considering removal of land from designated natural core and linkage areas.

Case against#

  • The bill gives the Minister and Lieutenant Governor in Council significant influence over the area’s boundaries and rules, while the initial plan-making process is not specified in the bill.
  • The plan could restrict land uses and buildings, and it would take priority over conflicting planning documents. The details needed to judge those effects are not yet available.
  • Some ministerial decisions are final and cannot be appealed, including certain amendments to municipal plans and zoning by-laws.
  • The bill does not estimate the cost of preparing, applying or enforcing a plan, or explain how those costs would be divided.