Agricultural Land Impact Assessments

Summary#

Bill 27, the Protecting Agricultural Land Act, 2022, would amend Ontario’s Planning Act. It would require an Agricultural Impact Assessment before certain zoning or permitted-use changes on land zoned for prescribed agricultural uses when the Act comes into force. Its stated goal is to protect agricultural land.

  • A local municipal council could not pass a zoning by-law changing that land’s zoning or permitted uses unless an assessment had been carried out under regulations.
  • The Minister would face the same condition when making certain zoning orders.
  • Regulations would set which agricultural uses are covered and govern the assessments.
  • The bill does not ban zoning changes outright or require a particular assessment result.

What it means for you#

  • Municipal councils and the Minister: They would have to ensure an assessment was carried out before making the covered zoning or use changes.
  • Owners of affected land: A proposed change to the land’s zoning or permitted uses could not proceed without an assessment. The bill does not say who must arrange or pay for it.
  • Other landowners and the public: The bill applies only to land that is zoned for agricultural uses prescribed by regulation on the day the Act comes into force. It does not directly change anyone’s zoning.
  • The supplied material does not include the current Planning Act, so the existing law and how much this would add to it could not be verified.

Money#

No publicly available information on estimated public or private costs.

  • The bill does not set a fee, provide funding, or estimate the cost of assessments.
  • It would authorize regulations governing assessments, but the bill does not say how they would be funded or staffed.

What is unclear#

  • Which agricultural uses and parcels would be covered; regulations would set this, but none are included in the supplied material.
  • What an assessment must examine, who may carry it out, and whether it must be independent.
  • Who would arrange and pay for an assessment, and how long it might take.
  • Whether the assessment would involve public input or require the decision-maker to act on its findings.
  • The supplied material does not establish whether the bill became law. It says the Act would start on Royal Assent.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to make agricultural impacts part of zoning decisions before land use changes.
  • A possible argument for requiring an assessment is that decision-makers would have information about agricultural impacts before changing zoning or permitted uses.
  • Applying the requirement to both municipal zoning by-laws and certain Minister’s orders could make the assessment condition apply through either route.

Case against#

  • An assessment is a condition for making a change, not a requirement to reject changes with adverse findings. The bill does not guarantee that covered land would remain agricultural.
  • The bill leaves key details—including which land is covered and what an assessment must contain—to regulations.
  • It is unclear who would arrange and pay for assessments, or whether the process could add costs or delay proposed changes.

Votes

The recorded vote on this bill, member by member.

  1. Division No. 2022120501

    Defeated96 members voted

    Second Reading of Bill 27

    AGAINST · 67FOR · 29

    67Against

    • PC67

    29For

    • NDP21
    • Liberal7
    • Green1