Care-home tenants gain clearer charges rules

Summary#

Bill 280, the Protecting Seniors’ Rights in Care Homes Act, 2021, would amend Ontario’s Residential Tenancies Act, 2006 and Retirement Homes Act, 2010. It would set information and price rules for care services and meals in care homes, and require a notice about tenant rights when a retirement home is closing. Its stated goal is to protect seniors’ rights in care homes.

  • Landlords would have to itemize charges for care services and meals in tenancy agreements and keep them consistent with the home’s current information package.
  • Landlords would have to provide information packages, keep them accurate and current, and make the latest version available in the care home. Material changes must be given to current tenants who received the original package.
  • A landlord and tenant could make a written agreement for additional care services or meals. The tenant could require an added service or meal to be reduced or stopped with at least 10 days’ notice.
  • Charges for care services and meals could not normally rise more than once in 12 months or by more than the percentage set under the Act’s existing rent-increase rule for that year. Regulations could allow exceptions, within limits.
  • A retirement-home licensee giving notice that the home is ceasing operation would have to tell residents that their tenant rights continue and that the closure notice is not a termination notice under the Residential Tenancies Act.

What it means for you#

  • Care-home tenants: You would get information about accommodation, included care and meal packages, and extra services and their fees. A material package revision would be given to you if you received the original package and are still a tenant.
  • Tenants choosing extra services or meals: The agreement must be written and charges itemized. It is void if obtained through coercion or a false, incomplete or misleading statement by the landlord or its agent. You could ask to reduce or stop an added service or meal with at least 10 days’ notice, and would not have to pay for it after the landlord is required to stop providing it.
  • Landlords: You would have new information, record-updating and charge-limit duties. For additional services or meals, the parties could agree in writing to a shorter or no notice period for changes to those charges under the Act’s notice rules.
  • Retirement-home residents: A closure notice would have to confirm that your tenant rights continue. The bill would not prevent a home from closing.
  • Scope: The bill addresses care-home tenancies and retirement-home closure notices; it does not create a general new service for all seniors.

Money#

The bill requires landlords to provide and update information, but the available material gives no cost estimate.

  • The bill contains no stated appropriation or estimate of public spending.
  • Landlords would have administrative duties, but their costs are not estimated.
  • The bill would limit charge increases; regulations could allow exceptions, subject to the bill’s limits.

What is unclear#

  • The bill leaves details of exceptional charge increases to future regulations, including how landlords must prove an increase is justified.
  • It does not define “material” differences or set out a process for resolving disputes about information packages or charges.
  • The supplied material does not include the current Acts, so the exact effect of changes to the Residential Tenancies Act’s exemption and applicability rules, and how the new rules fit with current processes, could not be verified.
  • The bill would start one year after Royal Assent, or earlier if proclaimed. The supplied material does not say whether or when that would happen.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that tenants need clear, comparable information about what care and meals cost before agreeing to a tenancy.
  • Requiring charges to match the information package could make it harder for a landlord to charge a tenant an amount not disclosed there.
  • Limits on how often and how much charges can rise could help tenants plan for care and meal costs.
  • The right to reduce or stop added services gives tenants a way to change those arrangements without continuing to pay after they stop.

Case against#

  • The bill leaves important details about permitted exceptional increases to regulations, so the limits’ practical effect would depend partly on rules not included here.
  • The bill does not spell out how disputes over charges or the accuracy of information packages would be handled.
  • Landlords would have to prepare and update packages and communicate changes, but the bill provides no estimate of the cost or staffing needed.
  • One concern is that allowing written agreements to shorten or remove notice for changes to charges on added services could reduce notice for tenants who agree to that term.