Transit Electrification Review Bill

Summary#

Bill 303, the Clean Trains Now Act, 2021, would amend Ontario’s Metrolinx Act, 2006. Its goal is to develop recommendations for changes to the Union Pearson Express, including electrification, fare integration and more passenger capacity. The bill would create a review committee, not require those changes to be made.

  • Metrolinx would have to establish the committee within 60 days after the bill receives Royal Assent. Its members would include representatives of named groups, such as transit workers, transit users and the construction industry.
  • The committee would recommend a plan, timeline and funding estimates for replacing diesel power with electrification; integrating fares so passengers can use all public transit routes in Toronto for up to two hours on a single fare no higher than a regular TTC fare; and increasing service capacity.
  • The committee would have to consult at least specified residents, transit users and people who work along the route, as well as anyone else it decides to consult.
  • The committee would have to report to Metrolinx and the Minister within six months of being established. The Minister would have to table the report within 30 days and tell the Legislature the Minister’s proposed response within 60 days after tabling it.

What it means for you#

  • Transit riders: The bill does not change fares, electrify trains or increase service. It requires recommendations about how those changes could be planned and funded.
  • People living or working along the route, and transit users in the Greater Toronto Area: The committee would have to consult these groups. The bill does not set how the consultation must work.
  • Metrolinx: It would have to establish the committee and receive its report.
  • Committee members: The Lieutenant Governor in Council may make regulations setting their pay and expense payments.
  • The Minister: The Minister would have to table the report and state proposed actions in response. The bill does not require the Minister to adopt the recommendations.
  • I could not verify what the current Metrolinx Act, 2006 already requires because the Act itself was not provided.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill requires Metrolinx to establish a committee, but gives no estimate of staffing or other costs.
  • Regulations may set pay and expense payments for committee members; no amounts are given.
  • The committee must recommend funding estimates for the proposed changes. The bill does not itself authorize funding for them.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not set rules for how committee members are selected, beyond saying Metrolinx chooses people it believes will contribute usefully and naming groups to include.
  • It does not define “full fare integration” or explain how a single fare would work across the transit routes involved.
  • It does not set out how the recommended changes would be approved, funded or carried out. No implementation duty, start date or decision process is provided.
  • No publicly available information in the supplied material explains how the committee’s work would fit with existing plans or requirements under the current Metrolinx Act.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to have electrification, fare integration and capacity considered together, with recommendations on a plan, timeline and funding.
  • Requiring public consultation could bring views from residents, workers and riders into the committee’s recommendations.
  • Requiring the Minister to table the report and state proposed actions would make the recommendations and the Minister’s response public.

Case against#

  • The bill requires recommendations, not changes to trains, fares or service. Those goals might not be acted on.
  • The bill does not require the Minister to accept the recommendations or give a reason for rejecting them.
  • The bill sets no cost limit or funding commitment for the committee, and no budget for carrying out its recommendations.
  • The committee’s composition and consultation methods are left partly to discretion, so the bill does not guarantee how people’s views will be gathered or weighed.