Transit Electrification Review Bill Moves Forward

Summary#

Bill 110, the Clean Trains Now Act, 2022, would amend Ontario’s Metrolinx Act, 2006. It would require a committee to review the Union Pearson Express and recommend a plan, timeline and funding estimates; its stated goal is to consider electrification, fare integration and increased capacity.

  • The Corporation under the Act would have to establish the committee within 60 days of Royal Assent. It would include representatives of the City of Toronto, TTC, transit workers, public transit users and construction industry, as well as members of the Ontario Professional Planners Institute and transportation engineers.
  • The committee would have to consult the public and specified groups, including area residents, transit users in the Greater Toronto Area, and people who work along the route.
  • The committee would recommend how and when to replace diesel power with electrification; the bill does not require that change to happen.
  • It would also recommend a plan for two-hour travel on all Toronto public transit routes for no more than a regular TTC fare, and ways to increase Union Pearson Express capacity. These are subjects for recommendations, not changes the bill itself makes.
  • The committee would report to the Corporation and the Minister within six months of being established. The Minister would have to table the report within 30 days and tell the Legislative Assembly within 60 days of tabling what actions the Minister proposes in response.

What it means for you#

  • Transit users: The bill would not itself change fares, routes, train frequency or capacity. It would require recommendations on those matters.
  • Residents, transit users and workers in the Greater Toronto Area: The committee would have to consult these groups, including residents and workers in areas along the route. The bill does not set out how or when consultations must happen.
  • Metrolinx and the Minister: Metrolinx would have to establish the committee and receive its report. The Minister would have to table the report and report proposed actions to the Assembly.
  • Committee members: The Lieutenant Governor in Council may make regulations setting their pay and expense payments; the bill does not require that such payments be set.

Money#

No cost estimate is provided in the supplied material.

  • The bill requires Metrolinx to establish and support a committee, but gives no staffing or operating-cost estimate.
  • It allows regulations to set committee members’ pay and expenses, but does not itself set amounts.
  • The committee must recommend funding estimates for its proposed plan. That is not an appropriation or a commitment to fund the recommendations.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied material does not include the parent Act, so it is not possible to verify how this committee duty compares with existing Metrolinx powers or duties, or to confirm current Union Pearson Express fares and service arrangements.
  • The bill does not explain how committee members would be chosen beyond the Corporation’s view that they can contribute usefully, or how the listed groups would be represented.
  • It does not set rules for consultation, such as notice, format or how input must affect recommendations.
  • It does not define “full fare integration” or specify how the proposed two-hour fare would work in practice.
  • The bill does not require the Minister or Metrolinx to adopt the recommendations or set a timeline for any resulting changes.

Case for#

  • A committee could assess electrification, fares and capacity together, and provide a plan, timeline and funding estimates before decisions are made.
  • Required consultation could bring input from transit users, local residents, workers and technical or industry representatives into that review.
  • Requiring the Minister to table the report and state proposed actions would make the recommendations and the Minister’s response public.

Case against#

  • The bill requires a review and recommendations, not electrification, lower fares or increased service. Those outcomes could remain unimplemented.
  • The committee’s membership and consultation methods are not tightly specified, which could affect whose views are heard and how recommendations are made.
  • The bill gives no estimate of the cost of the committee or any future changes, and does not commit funding to carry them out.