Summary#
Bill 34, the Green Energy Repeal Act, 2018, is now law. It repeals the Green Energy Act, 2009, moves some of its provisions into the Electricity Act, 1998, and amends other Acts, including the Planning Act and Environmental Protection Act. Its stated goal is to change how renewable energy projects are handled and keep energy-conservation and efficiency rules in law.
- The Lieutenant Governor in Council may make regulations that designate certain goods, services, technologies, renewable energy projects, sources or testing projects. In prescribed circumstances, a designation can make some legal restrictions—including municipal or condominium rules, property encumbrances and agreements—inoperative. Restrictions in Acts or regulations are excluded, and regulations may set further exceptions.
- Regulations may require public agencies, including municipalities if prescribed, to make and implement energy plans, meet targets or standards, and publish plans. Regulations may also require prescribed people or businesses to report energy or water information. The Minister may publish or share reported information.
- Energy providers that are prescribed must make prescribed energy-use data available to account holders or people they authorize. Prescribed appliances and products cannot be sold or leased unless they meet prescribed efficiency rules and have required labels; regulations may also set testing and labelling fees.
- The Planning Act no longer exempts renewable energy undertakings from the listed planning rules and controls. It also removes certain subdivision-control exemptions. Appeals are barred for specified official-plan and zoning amendment matters involving renewable energy undertakings, but the Minister may appeal.
- The Environmental Protection Act may be amended by regulation to prohibit issuing or renewing renewable energy approvals in prescribed circumstances, which may include when electricity demand has not been demonstrated under the regulations.
What it means for you#
- Municipalities and public agencies: Regulations may require you to prepare, publish and carry out energy plans, or meet energy targets or standards. The Act does not itself set the detailed requirements.
- Renewable energy developers and nearby property owners: Renewable projects are subject to more of the listed planning rules. But if regulations designate a project or activity, some non-statutory restrictions may not apply in prescribed circumstances. The bill does not itself designate particular projects.
- People seeking planning changes: Appeals are barred for specified requests to amend official plans or zoning by-laws to permit renewable energy undertakings. The Minister’s appeal exception remains.
- Energy customers and providers: If regulations prescribe a provider, it must make specified energy data available to an account holder or someone the account holder authorizes. The bill does not require every provider to do so immediately.
- Product sellers and lessors: Prescribed appliances and products must meet prescribed efficiency requirements and carry required labels. The bill does not set which products or standards directly.
- The public: The bill does not itself ban renewable energy projects, create a new benefit, or set a new tax.
Money#
No publicly available information on the bill’s overall cost.
- The bill allows regulations to require agency plans, reporting and energy-data systems, but the materials give no staffing or implementation cost estimates.
- Regulations may set fees for appliance testing or labelling, and for some energy-data certifications. No fee amounts are set in the bill.
- No tax, appropriation or grant amount is specified.
What is unclear#
- Which agencies, businesses, properties, products, energy providers and data will be covered depends on regulations.
- The bill does not set the detailed targets, reporting rules, efficiency standards, data-access methods or dates for most requirements.
- It is unclear which projects or restrictions may be designated, or what circumstances would trigger a ban on issuing or renewing renewable energy approvals.
- The bill allows transition regulations for planning changes, including regulations that can make the former exemption rules apply to specified projects or circumstances. The materials do not say whether such regulations were made.
- The supplied material does not include the full former Act or current consolidated Acts and regulations, so the exact prior requirements and current operation of all affected provisions could not be independently checked.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to restore planning controls for renewable energy projects while retaining tools for conservation and efficiency.
- Allowing regulations to require energy plans, reporting and efficiency standards could give the province ways to set requirements for particular agencies, buildings or products.
- Making energy data available to customers or authorized third parties could support access to information about energy use.
- Allowing renewable projects to be designated to overcome some restrictions could help address barriers to renewable energy or access to electricity networks.
Case against#
- Many practical duties and protections depend on future regulations, so the bill itself leaves important choices to the government.
- The appeal limits may reduce the ability of people or groups to challenge specified planning decisions involving renewable energy undertakings.
- Designations can make some municipal, condominium, property or agreement restrictions inoperative, which may limit the control those rules provide in prescribed cases.
- The transition provisions allow regulations to apply retroactively and restrict legal claims linked to the repeal or transition regulations. The materials do not explain how those powers would be used.