Summary#
Bill 63, Restoring Planning Powers to Municipalities Act, 2018, would amend Ontario’s Planning Act. Its stated goal is to reverse exemptions for renewable energy undertakings from the Act’s usual planning rules. The bill removes several definitions and exemptions and repeals one section; the supplied material does not include the Planning Act, so I could not verify the exact effect against the Act as it currently stands.
- The bill would remove definitions for renewable energy facilities, projects, testing facilities, testing projects and undertakings.
- It would repeal two provisions that the bill’s explanatory note identifies as part of the exemptions, as well as section 62.0.2.
- The explanatory note says the changes would end exemptions from usual planning rules, including provincial policy statements and plans, municipal official plans, zoning and demolition-control bylaws, and development-permit rules.
- The bill does not itself set up a new planning office, approval process, funding program or fee.
What it means for you#
- Municipalities: The bill is intended to return planning powers over renewable energy undertakings to municipalities. If enacted, those projects could be subject to relevant Planning Act rules. The bill does not say that every project would require a particular approval.
- Renewable energy project proponents: The exemptions described in the explanatory note would be removed. What planning rules would apply to a particular project would depend on the Planning Act and other applicable rules.
- Residents and taxpayers: The bill does not directly change taxes, create a public benefit, or set a new service for residents.
Money#
No cost estimate is in the available material.
- The bill sets no appropriation, fee or fine.
- Any added planning work or costs for municipalities or project proponents are not estimated.
What is unclear#
- The supplied material does not include the Planning Act, so the precise current exemptions and the exact legal effect of each repeal could not be checked.
- The bill does not explain how it would apply to projects already underway or approved.
- It does not set out application steps, decision timelines, appeals or transition rules.
- It removes the listed definitions, but the supplied material does not show how that would affect other references to those terms in the Act.
- The bill gives no estimate of added municipal workload or cost.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to let municipalities apply planning rules to renewable energy undertakings instead of exempting them from the usual system.
- A possible argument for the bill is that local planning decisions should be able to consider these projects under rules that also apply to other development.
- Restoring municipal planning powers could give municipalities more influence over how projects fit with official plans, zoning bylaws and other planning rules.
Case against#
- Removing exemptions could make renewable energy projects subject to more planning requirements, which may add steps or uncertainty for project proponents.
- The bill does not explain how municipal planning powers would interact with provincial plans and policies or with other approvals.
- Without transition rules, it is unclear how the changes would affect projects already underway or approved.
- The bill provides no funding or cost estimate for any additional work.