Summary#
Bill 39, the Accessible Parking and Towing Industry Review Committee Act, 2018, would create a new Act; it does not amend another Act. Its stated goal is to have an advisory committee examine accessible parking and the towing industry and recommend changes.
- The Minister of Government and Consumer Services must establish the committee within 90 days after the Act receives Royal Assent.
- The committee must include people with accessibility expertise, people representing people with disabilities, towing-industry experts, and consumer-protection advocates. The Minister chooses the members.
- Within eight months of being established, the committee must report recommendations on an economically feasible and fair accessible-parking system, and on towing-industry training, licensing, and consumer protection.
- Within 60 days of receiving the report, the Minister must tell the Assembly which recommendations the Minister will implement within the next five years. The bill does not require the Minister to implement every recommendation.
What it means for you#
- People with disabilities: The committee must examine accessible parking and recommend a system that is economically feasible and fair to their interests. The bill does not itself change parking rules, permits, or access to parking.
- Towing businesses and workers: The committee must consider training and licensing in the towing industry. The bill does not itself change licensing or training requirements.
- Consumers: The committee must consider towing-related consumer protection. The bill does not create a new complaint process or change consumer rights.
- Government: The Minister must establish the committee and report to the Assembly on which recommendations the Minister will implement. The committee is advisory; it does not make binding rules.
Money#
No publicly available information on the bill’s costs is included in the supplied material.
- The Lieutenant Governor in Council may make regulations setting committee members’ pay and expense payments; the bill does not set amounts or require such payments.
- No estimate is given for committee or government administrative costs.
What is unclear#
- The bill does not set out how the committee will gather evidence, who may make submissions, or how it will reach its recommendations.
- The Minister chooses members, but the bill gives no process for choosing them or details about the committee’s size.
- The bill does not explain how recommendations the Minister chooses to implement would be put into effect.
- The bill does not describe how this review would relate to existing accessible-parking or towing rules.
- The definition of “person with a disability” refers to Ontario Regulation 581, but the supplied material does not include that regulation.
Case for#
- A possible argument for the bill is that one committee would examine both accessible parking and towing-related concerns before the government decides what changes to make.
- Requiring expertise and representation from people with disabilities, the towing industry, and consumer advocates could bring different perspectives into the review.
- Requiring the Minister to tell the Assembly which recommendations will be implemented would make the Minister’s choices public.
Case against#
- The bill does not require the government to implement the committee’s recommendations; the Minister only has to identify which ones the Minister will implement.
- The bill sets deadlines for creating the committee and reporting, but does not require public input or specify how the committee must conduct its review.
- A possible trade-off is that the committee’s recommendations could be made without a process or selection rules detailed in the bill.
- The bill does not set a budget or explain how the committee’s work and any later changes would be paid for.