Summary#
Bill 57, the Transportation Systems Improvement Advisory Committee Act, 2018, would create a new law; it does not amend another Act. Its stated goal is to improve highway incident management, accessible parking, and the use of technology to make transportation safer and more accessible.
- The Ministers of Transportation and Community Safety and Correctional Services, together with the Ontario Provincial Police Commissioner, must establish an advisory committee within 60 days after the Act receives Royal Assent.
- The committee must study highway incident management, the system of accessible parking for people with disabilities, and technology for safer, more accessible transportation.
- The committee must include people with relevant expertise and people representing affected groups, including municipalities, police, emergency medical services, road users, and people with disabilities.
- Within eight months of the committee’s establishment, it must report recommendations to the two Ministers on specified topics, including incident detection and clearance, driver education, accessible parking, and highway safety.
- Within 60 days after receiving the report, each Minister must tell the Assembly which recommendations they will implement. The bill does not require them to implement any recommendation.
- The Lieutenant Governor in Council may make regulations setting committee members’ pay and expenses.
What it means for you#
- Drivers and other road users: The committee must consider ways to improve highway incident response and information for drivers. The bill does not itself change road rules or create a new highway service.
- People with disabilities: The committee must report on accessible parking and recommend a system that is economically feasible and fair to their interests. The bill does not itself change parking eligibility or how accessible parking permits are issued.
- Municipalities, police, emergency medical services, and other named groups: People representing these interests are to be included on the committee. The bill does not set the committee’s size or require a particular number of representatives from each group.
- The two Ministers and the OPP Commissioner: They must establish the committee. Each Minister must later report to the Assembly which recommendations they will implement.
- The public: The bill requires a committee report and ministerial statements about implementation, but does not require the committee’s report to be made public.
Money#
No publicly available information on the bill’s total cost or the cost of the committee.
- The bill allows regulations to set committee members’ remuneration and expenses, but does not require that pay be set or give an estimate.
- It requires the three officials to establish the committee and requires the committee to do its work and report. It gives no staffing or operating-cost estimate.
What is unclear#
- The bill does not set rules for selecting members, the committee’s size, or how it will make decisions.
- It does not set out how the committee will gather evidence or consult affected groups.
- It does not say whether or how the committee’s report will be published.
- The bill does not set deadlines or a process for carrying out recommendations that a Minister says they will implement.
- It does not explain how any future recommendations would relate to existing programs or rules.
Case for#
- A single committee could examine incident response, accessible parking, and transportation technology together, and report recommendations to the responsible Ministers.
- The required membership includes people with expertise and representatives of groups affected by highway incidents and accessible parking.
- Requiring each Minister to tell the Assembly which recommendations they will implement would make their intended response public.
Case against#
- The committee’s work is advisory: Ministers must report which recommendations they will implement, but do not have to implement them.
- The bill sets deadlines for creating the committee and delivering its report, but leaves its membership size, selection process, and working methods open.
- The bill permits regulations on members’ pay and expenses without providing a cost estimate or funding limit.