Social Assistance Research Commission Bill

Summary#

Bill 30, the Ministry of Community and Social Services Amendment Act (Social Assistance Research Commission), 2018, would amend Ontario’s Ministry of Community and Social Services Act to require an advisory commission. Its stated goal is to produce research-based recommendations on social assistance rates and policy; it would not set benefit rates or change eligibility itself.

  • The Lieutenant Governor in Council would appoint nine members, including people with specified expertise and at least one current or recent Ontario Works recipient and one current or recent Ontario Disability Support Program recipient.
  • The Commission would define regions using economic geography and living costs, then recommend social assistance rates for each region every year.
  • Its rate recommendations would consider basic expenses such as food, shelter, transportation, phone and internet service, clothing, personal needs, children’s needs, and other costs it considers basic. It would also examine added costs for people with disabilities and people on Ontario Works facing long-term barriers to employment.
  • The Commission could recommend extra periodic benefits for Ontario Works recipients facing long-term barriers to employment.
  • It would also recommend policy on social assistance and precarious work, child support, and workplace-injury benefits. The Minister must publish its reports within 30 days and respond publicly to annual-report recommendations within 60 days.

What it means for you#

  • People receiving Ontario Works or disability support: The bill would not directly change your payment, eligibility, or benefits. It would require recommendations about rates and related policies, but not require the government to adopt them.
  • People with disabilities and other groups named in the bill: Their economic challenges would be considered in the Commission’s work. The bill sets minimum membership requirements for disability expertise, Indigenous expertise, and people with current or recent experience receiving Ontario Works or disability support.
  • Minister and government: The Minister would appoint the chair, could direct the Commission to report on living standards, and must publish the reports and a written response to annual recommendations.
  • General public: The reports and the Minister’s response would be public. The bill does not require the Commission to consult the public or any specific group.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill provides for a nine-member Commission and allows regulations to cover members’ remuneration and the retention of experts, but gives no cost estimate or budget.
  • It does not set social assistance rates or authorize new benefit payments.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not explain how the Commission would measure costs, define “basic necessities,” or decide the boundaries of regions.
  • It does not set rules for how recommendations must be reached, require consultation, or create an appeal or oversight process.
  • It does not require the Minister or government to accept recommendations or explain what action will follow the Minister’s response.
  • Regulations would govern some matters, including appointments and remuneration; their contents are not included here.
  • The parent Act was not supplied, so existing related powers, bodies, and duties could not be checked against current law.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that regional cost research could make rate recommendations more responsive to differences in living costs across Ontario.
  • The required analysis names a broad range of basic expenses, as well as additional costs for people with disabilities and people facing long-term barriers to employment.
  • Requiring public reports and a public ministerial response could make the recommendations and the government’s response visible.

Case against#

  • The Commission could recommend rates and policies, but the bill does not require the government to change benefits. Its work might not lead to a practical change for recipients.
  • The bill does not specify a method for measuring costs or deciding which expenses count as basic necessities, leaving important choices to the Commission.
  • The bill does not require consultation with recipients or other affected groups, or set a process for explaining how their views are considered.