Cap-and-Trade Wind-Down Bill Targets Emissions

Summary#

Bill 4, the Cap and Trade Cancellation Act, 2018, creates a new Act and repeals Ontario’s Climate Change Mitigation and Low-carbon Economy Act, 2016. It winds down the cap-and-trade program and requires the government to set greenhouse-gas reduction targets, while the Minister must prepare a climate change plan and regular progress reports; these duties do not guarantee particular emissions reductions. The Act was enacted, but its start date is to be set by proclamation.

  • The government must make targets public. The Minister must prepare and publish a climate plan, with the Lieutenant Governor in Council’s approval, and regular progress reports.
  • Certain cap-and-trade instruments held by participants on July 3, 2018, are retired based on attributed emissions; the other instruments covered by the Act are cancelled.
  • The Crown must pay compensation to eligible participants under rules and limits in the Act and regulations. Several named categories of participants are excluded unless regulations allow payment.
  • The Act bars specified claims and proceedings against the Crown and related people over the cancellation and wind-down, including proceedings already underway.
  • The existing cap-and-trade account is continued as the Cap and Trade Wind Down Account, with spending permitted for listed wind-down, administration and compensation costs.

What it means for you#

  • People and organizations that were cap-and-trade participants on July 3, 2018: Eligible instruments held then are retired up to the amount of emissions attributed over a prescribed period. Instruments not retired, including instruments created but never distributed, are cancelled. Instruments assigned a 2021 vintage year are not eligible for retirement under this rule.
  • Participants seeking compensation: The Act sets a maximum number of instruments for which compensation may be paid; regulations determine payment amounts and may set further conditions or adjustments. Market participants and several named energy-sector participants are not entitled to compensation unless regulations provide otherwise.
  • The Crown and related officials: The Act prevents specified legal claims about the program’s repeal and wind-down. It also deems certain proceedings already started to be dismissed.
  • The public: The government must publish its targets, and the Minister must publish the climate plan and reports. The Act does not itself set a specific target or require a particular emissions-reduction policy.
  • Indigenous peoples: The Act says it does not reduce existing Aboriginal or treaty rights recognized under section 35 of the Constitution Act, 1982.

Money#

The Act authorizes spending from the wind-down account, up to its balance, and requires compensation payments under its rules; no cost estimate is provided.

  • The account may pay for administration, repeal and wind-down costs, certain existing initiatives and their wind-down, and compensation and related costs.
  • Compensation is paid from money appropriated in the account or otherwise appropriated by the Legislature.
  • No tax or fee change is set out in the supplied material.

What is unclear#

  • No publicly available information is provided about the proclamation date that brings the Act into force.
  • Regulations determine key details, including the emissions period, compensation amounts, eligibility conditions and adjustments. Those details are not in the supplied material.
  • The Act requires regular progress reports but does not specify how often they must be prepared or what the plan must contain.
  • Where the Minister proposes to determine a participant’s attributed emissions, the participant must receive notice and an opportunity to be heard under rules set by regulation. Other application, review or appeal procedures are not set out here.
  • No process for involving Indigenous communities in the plan is specified in the supplied material.

Case for#

  • The Act sets out a way to close the cap-and-trade program, cancel its instruments and compensate some participants under stated limits.
  • Linking retirement and some compensation limits to attributed emissions could be seen as distinguishing instruments connected to emissions from other holdings.
  • Public targets, a climate plan and regular progress reports preserve climate-planning and reporting duties after the previous Act is repealed.
  • Using an existing account for listed wind-down costs may provide a defined source of funds, subject to its balance and legislative appropriations.

Case against#

  • Participants lose the value of instruments that are cancelled, and the Act excludes several categories from compensation unless regulations make an exception.
  • The Act broadly bars claims and proceedings over the wind-down, including some proceedings already underway. This limits legal remedies for affected people and organizations.
  • Key compensation rules and emissions calculations depend on regulations, so the Act alone does not show who will receive how much.
  • The climate duties do not specify a target level, required actions or a timetable for reducing emissions.

Votes

2 recorded votes on this bill, newest first.

  1. Division No. 2018103101

    Passed116 members voted

    Third Reading of Bill 4

    FOR · 74AGAINST · 42

    74For

    • PC74

    42Against

    • NDP35
    • Liberal6
    • Green1
  2. Division No. 2018100302

    Passed109 members voted

    Motion for allocation of time on Bill 4, An Act respecting the preparation of a climate change plan, providing for the wind down of the cap and trade program and…

    FOR · 70AGAINST · 39

    70For

    • PC70

    39Against

    • NDP35
    • Liberal3
    • Green1