Summary#
Bill 44, the Ending Automobile Insurance Discrimination in the Greater Toronto Area Act, 2018, would amend Ontario’s Insurance Act. Its stated goal is to prevent automobile insurance rates from differing because a person lives in one Greater Toronto Area municipality or area rather than another. The bill would take effect on Royal Assent.
- The Superintendent would have to refuse approval of an insurer’s risk classification system if it uses a person’s geographic region, treats parts of the GTA as separate regions, and would produce different rates for the same coverage and category within the GTA.
- An insurer could not offer, enter into or renew a GTA resident’s policy if its rate was based on such a system and would differ if the resident lived in another GTA municipality or area.
- The bill defines the GTA as Toronto and the regional municipalities of Durham, Halton, Peel and York.
- The rule concerns geographic location within the GTA; it does not require identical rates for all drivers or prevent rates from differing for other reasons.
What it means for you#
- GTA drivers: If the bill became law, an insurer could not use the described location-based system to set your rate. The bill does not promise that your rate would fall or that it would match another driver’s.
- Drivers outside the GTA: The bill’s rules apply to GTA residents; it does not directly change your rates.
- Insurers: They would have to follow the restrictions when applying for approval of a risk classification system and when offering, entering into or renewing affected policies.
- Superintendent: The bill would require the Superintendent to refuse approval when the stated conditions are met.
Money#
No publicly available information on the bill’s implementation costs.
- The bill sets no appropriation, fee, fine or compensation payment.
- It does not estimate costs to insurers or any effect on premiums.
What is unclear#
- The supplied material does not include the current Insurance Act, so the existing approval rules and how this bill would interact with them could not be independently verified.
- The bill does not explain how insurers would show that a rate difference results from geographic location rather than another factor.
- It does not set out a process, timeline, appeal route or reporting duty for applying or enforcing the new rules.
- It does not say how existing policies or approved systems would be handled when the law takes effect.
- The bill’s start date is Royal Assent, but the supplied material does not say whether or when the bill became law.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to stop rate differences between GTA municipalities when those differences result from using the municipality or area as a separate geographic risk category.
- Treating the GTA as one geographic area for this purpose could make it easier for residents to avoid rate differences tied to where within the GTA they live.
- The rule still allows insurers to set different rates based on factors other than the prohibited geographic distinction.
Case against#
- One concern is that insurers would be barred from using within-GTA location differences in the specified systems even if they consider those differences relevant to risk.
- The bill does not explain how geographic factors would be separated from other factors when determining why a rate differs.
- It is unclear how the new rule would be enforced or how existing policies and approved systems would be treated.