Bill caps auto-insurance rate approvals

Summary#

Bill 90, Lower Automobile Insurance Rates Act, 2019, would amend Ontario’s Insurance Act. Its stated goal is to lower automobile insurance rates, by limiting which rates the regulator may approve. The Insurance Act was not supplied, so I could not verify how these rules would compare with current rate-approval law.

  • When considering an automobile insurance rate, the Superintendent must require the insurer to provide its Ontario auto-insurance equity, return on equity and detailed operating costs.
  • The Superintendent must refuse a rate if the insurer’s return on equity is above 7% for approvals in 2019–2021, or above a later prescribed amount that starts at 7% and is adjusted for capital-market changes.
  • Operating costs would be capped at a declining share of premiums, from 20% in 2019 to 17.5% in 2024 and later. The Superintendent may approve a rate above this cost limit if following it would be unreasonable or unjust; there is no similar exception to the return-on-equity limit.
  • Insurers must annually provide operating-cost information, including corporate overhead, executive pay and benefits, marketing and customer-acquisition costs, commissions, and legal expenses. It must cover operations in Ontario and across Canada.
  • Insurers must also annually report total premiums paid, accident-claim counts and claim payouts, grouped by the first three characters of insured people’s postal codes.

What it means for you#

  • Insurers: They would have to provide the specified information when the Superintendent considers a rate, and submit the two annual reports. A rate above the return-on-equity limit could not be approved; the operating-cost limit has the stated exception.
  • Insured people: The bill does not directly set each person’s premium or require refunds. It limits rate approvals under specified financial tests; whether that would lower a particular person’s rate is not stated.
  • Regulator: The Superintendent would have new information-gathering duties and limits on rate approvals. The bill also provides for replacing “Superintendent” with “Chief Executive Officer”; that change would start only on a day set by proclamation.
  • General public: The postal-code information is to be reported to the Superintendent. The bill does not say that it must be made public.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill gives no estimate of government spending, insurer compliance costs, or savings.
  • Insurers would have to prepare and provide additional information. The bill does not specify staffing or a funding source for the regulator’s new duties.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not define how return on equity or operating costs would be calculated, or how costs would be allocated between Ontario and Canada.
  • For 2022 onward, the return-on-equity limit depends on a prescribed amount. The text does not set out the adjustment formula or say what that amount would be.
  • The operating-cost limit compares costs with premiums collected, but the text does not specify the geographic scope of that premium total.
  • The bill does not say whether the annual reports would be published, or how the regulator would check them.
  • The text does not explain how the limits would interact with existing rate-approval rules. Passage and start dates are also uncertain: most provisions would start on Royal Assent, but the change to “Chief Executive Officer” requires a later proclamation.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to stop approval of rates that would allow insurers to exceed specified returns or operating-cost limits.
  • Requiring detailed cost information could give the regulator information relevant to rate decisions.
  • Postal-code summaries of premiums and claims could help show how those totals vary across areas, if the information is used for that purpose.

Case against#

  • The bill sets financial limits without defining key calculations in its text. That could leave important rate decisions dependent on rules or judgments not explained here.
  • A uniform operating-cost limit may not fit every insurer’s circumstances. The Superintendent can make an exception when applying it would be unreasonable or unjust, but the bill does not explain how that judgment would be made.
  • The bill does not guarantee lower premiums for any individual. It also does not say how the reported area-level figures would affect rate decisions or be made useful to the public.

Votes

The recorded vote on this bill, member by member.

  1. Division No. 2019041804

    Defeated88 members voted

    Second Reading of Bill 90

    AGAINST · 58FOR · 30

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    58Against

    • PC58

    30For

    • NDP30