Summary#
Bill 12, the Ending Automobile Insurance Discrimination in the Greater Toronto Area Act, 2022, would amend Ontario’s Insurance Act. Its stated goal is to prevent automobile insurance rates from differing because of where a person lives within the Greater Toronto Area (GTA). The bill would take effect on Royal Assent.
- The Chief Executive Officer of the Financial Services Regulatory Authority of Ontario (FSRA) must refuse to approve an insurer’s risk-classification system if it uses where someone lives in the GTA, treats GTA municipalities or areas separately, and could produce different rates for the same coverage or category.
- An insurer must not offer, enter into or renew a GTA resident’s contract if its rate was based on such a system and would differ if the person lived in another GTA municipality or area.
- The bill defines the GTA as Toronto and the regional municipalities of Durham, Halton, Peel and York.
- The bill does not require all GTA drivers to pay the same premium: it targets differences linked to residence within the GTA, not differences based on other risk factors.
What it means for you#
- GTA residents: If enacted, your place of residence within the GTA could not be used through the described system to produce a different rate for the same coverage or category. Your premium could still differ for other reasons.
- Residents outside the GTA: The bill does not directly change how their automobile insurance rates are set.
- Insurers: They would be barred from using the described systems to offer, enter into or renew affected GTA policies.
- FSRA’s Chief Executive Officer: The CEO would have a duty to refuse approval of systems that meet the bill’s conditions.
Money#
No publicly available information on cost is included in the supplied material.
- The bill gives no estimate of public spending, insurer costs, savings or changes to premiums.
- The CEO would have to refuse approval of qualifying systems, and insurers would have to comply with the new restriction. The bill gives no cost or staffing estimate for that work.
What is unclear#
- The Insurance Act itself was not supplied, so the current approval rules and how this proposal would fit with them could not be verified.
- The bill does not explain how insurers or FSRA would determine whether a rate difference results from residence within the GTA.
- It does not set out new review, appeal, reporting or enforcement processes.
- The supplied material does not say whether the bill became law.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to stop a person’s GTA municipality or area from affecting the rate for the same coverage or category.
- Treating the GTA as one geographic area for this purpose could prevent insurers from charging different rates based on distinctions between places within it.
- The rule would apply both to FSRA approval of classification systems and to insurers’ offers and contracts.
Case against#
- A possible trade-off is that the bill would bar rate differences tied to location within the GTA even where an insurer’s system uses those geographic distinctions to classify risk.
- The bill does not explain how the regulator would identify when a rate difference is caused by residence rather than other factors.
- The text does not specify what penalties or other consequences would apply if an insurer failed to follow the prohibition.