Summary#
The bill’s text creates a new law; it does not amend an existing Act. Its short title in the text is the Protecting Our Pets Act, 2018, although the supplied bill listing calls it the 2019 Act. Its stated goal is to review the care of companion animals kept for certain commercial or public-facing purposes and recommend possible next steps.
- Within 90 days after Royal Assent, the Minister of Community Safety and Correctional Services must establish an advisory committee.
- The committee must review the quality of care for companion animals kept for breeding, exhibition, entertainment, boarding, hire or sale. “Companion animal” means a dog, cat or animal prescribed by regulation that a person keeps for companionship.
- The committee must report within eight months. Its recommendations must address possible care standards, possible restrictions on breeders who contravene the Ontario Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals Act, and two proposed public education campaigns.
- The Minister must publish the report and, within 60 days, tell the Legislative Assembly which recommendations the Minister will implement, propose legislation for, or recommend to the Government for implementation within three years.
- The bill does not itself set new care standards, restrict breeders, create the proposed campaigns, or require the recommendations to be implemented.
What it means for you#
- People who keep companion animals for the listed purposes: The bill creates no new care rules or enforcement action against you. It requires a committee to consider possible standards and other recommendations.
- Other pet owners: The bill creates no new duties or services for you. The committee may recommend an education campaign aimed at people considering getting an animal from a breeder who has neglected or harmed it.
- Minister and Government: The Minister must establish the committee, publish its report and report planned next steps to the Assembly. The Minister must also make regulations if adding other animals to the definition is desired, but is not required to add any.
- Committee and named groups: The Minister selects committee members believed able to contribute. The bill lists animal caregivers, people who keep animals for the specified purposes, professional support providers including veterinarians, and representatives of the Ontario Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals and animal shelters.
- People who contravene the referenced animal-welfare Act: The committee must consider recommending an education campaign explaining that Act and how their actions contravene it. The bill does not itself create that campaign or change the Act’s rules.
Money#
No cost information is in the available material.
- The Lieutenant Governor in Council may make regulations setting committee members’ pay and expense reimbursements; the bill does not require a particular amount.
- No publicly available information gives an estimate of committee, staffing, or other costs.
What is unclear#
- The supplied material does not include the Ontario Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals Act, so its current requirements and how this bill would interact with them cannot be verified.
- The bill does not set committee size, selection details, meeting rules, or how it will gather evidence.
- “Quality of care” and “professional support” are not defined in the bill.
- The bill does not require the Minister or Government to implement the committee’s recommendations. It requires the Minister to report which steps they plan to take.
- The bill does not give a start date beyond Royal Assent; passage is not confirmed in the supplied material.
Case for#
- A committee could bring animal caregivers, businesses, veterinarians, shelters and the named animal-welfare organization into one review.
- The report must consider standards, possible legislative or regulatory changes, and education—not just describe the issue.
- Publishing the report and requiring the Minister to explain intended next steps would make the recommendations and the Government’s response public.
Case against#
- The bill creates a review and reporting process, not new protections or care standards. Animals would not receive new legal protections from this bill alone.
- The Minister and Government are not required to carry out the recommendations; the bill requires a statement of intended action.
- The bill does not specify the committee’s size, evidence-gathering process, or how it will address the care of animals in practice.
- Costs are unknown, and the bill allows regulations for committee members’ pay and expenses without setting limits.