Plan to Conserve Watersheds and Reform Planning

Summary#

Bill 139, the Building Better Communities and Conserving Watersheds Act, 2017, became Ontario law as Chapter 23 of the Statutes of Ontario, 2017. It creates two Acts, renames and changes the Ontario Municipal Board, and amends planning and conservation-authority laws. Its stated goal is to support better communities and conserve watersheds; that is a goal, not a guaranteed result.

  • The Ontario Municipal Board continues as the Local Planning Appeal Tribunal (LPAT), not as a new independent tribunal. For many official-plan and zoning appeals, the bill limits the issues that can be appealed and changes what the Tribunal may do.
  • A new Local Planning Appeal Support Centre must provide eligible people with land-use information, guidance on Tribunal procedures, and advice or representation. It may also provide other services set by regulation.
  • Municipal official plans must include policies on affordable housing and on reducing greenhouse-gas emissions and adapting to climate change.
  • Conservation authorities must prohibit specified activities in certain areas unless an exception applies or a permit is issued. The bill also gives authorities enforcement powers and raises possible fines.
  • Conservation authorities must provide programs and services required by regulation. They may also provide services for municipalities by agreement, and other services they decide would further their objects.
  • Municipalities must pay their apportioned shares of conservation authorities’ project capital costs and yearly operating expenses.

What it means for you#

  • People involved in planning appeals: For many appeals about official plans and zoning, an appeal must explain how the decision conflicts with provincial policy or plans, or with an upper-tier municipality’s official plan. The Tribunal generally dismisses an appeal after a hearing, but in specified cases gives the municipality another chance to decide. The bill does not remove every kind of planning appeal.
  • People seeking appeal help: The Support Centre must make its services available across Ontario, but it sets eligibility criteria subject to regulations and its financial resources. The bill does not guarantee that every applicant will receive representation.
  • Landowners and developers in conservation-authority areas: The bill prohibits activities such as interfering with watercourses or wetlands, and development in listed hazard and other areas, unless an exception applies or the authority issues a permit. A permit is not automatic. Authorities may appoint officers to inspect land, issue stop orders and enforce permit conditions. Officers cannot enter a dwelling or other building under the entry powers described here.
  • People considering or carrying out prohibited activities: A court may impose fines of up to $50,000 on an individual or $1 million on a corporation, plus daily fines if an offence continues. An individual may also face up to three months in jail. A court may order removal of development and repair or rehabilitation of damage.
  • Municipalities: They must pay apportioned conservation-authority costs. They must also address affordable housing and climate change in official plans. The bill does not directly change personal income taxes or create a direct payment to residents.

Money#

No publicly available information on the total cost of implementation.

  • The Support Centre must submit an annual budget to the Minister for approval. Its board members may receive remuneration and expenses; the bill gives no amounts.
  • Conservation authorities may charge fees only for classes of services the Minister identifies. The authority sets the fee unless regulations set an amount. Each authority must publish a fee policy and schedule.
  • Municipalities must pay their shares of authorities’ project capital costs and operating expenses. The bill does not give total amounts or say how much any municipality will owe.
  • The Tribunal may charge fees for proceedings and services, subject to approval by the Attorney General. It may waive some or all fees for people determined to be low-income under its rules.

What is unclear#

  • Many provisions were to start on dates set by proclamation. The supplied material does not give those dates, so it does not establish when each change took effect.
  • The full parent Acts were not supplied, so the current law and every change from it could not be independently checked against their complete text.
  • Regulations are needed to define key conservation-law terms, identify required programs, set cost-apportionment rules and establish details for permits and fees.
  • The bill does not set out how many people the Support Centre will help, how it will decide which services to prioritize, or how its funding will meet demand.
  • It is unclear how conservation authorities’ new powers and programs will overlap with existing municipal services or other rules.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to conserve watersheds by setting prohibitions for risky activities and giving authorities permit, inspection and enforcement powers.
  • Requiring climate-change policies in official plans could make local planning address both emissions and adaptation.
  • A province-wide Support Centre could give eligible people information, procedural guidance or representation in planning matters.
  • Requiring municipalities to pay apportioned authority costs makes those costs a shared municipal responsibility, with review routes for some cost allocations.

Case against#

  • Restricting many planning appeals to consistency with provincial or upper-tier plans may leave less room to challenge a decision on other grounds.
  • In specified planning appeals, oral participants cannot present evidence or call or question witnesses. That may limit how parties can explain their case.
  • The bill leaves important definitions, service rules, fees and cost-apportionment details to later regulations or authorities, making the practical effects hard to predict from the Act alone.
  • Conservation-authority costs must be paid by municipalities, but the bill does not estimate those costs or say how they may affect municipal budgets.
  • The Support Centre must provide services, but its eligibility rules and priorities depend on its resources; the bill does not guarantee equal access to advice or representation.

Votes

4 recorded votes on this bill, newest first.

  1. Division No. 2017121203

    Passed91 members voted

    Motion for closure on Third Reading of Bill 139

    FOR · 49AGAINST · 42

    49For

    • Liberal49

    42Against

    • PC26
    • NDP15
    • Independent1
  2. Division No. 2017121204

    Passed87 members voted

    Third Reading of Bill 139

    FOR · 86AGAINST · 1

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    86For

    • Liberal49
    • PC22
    • NDP15

    1Against

    • Independent1
  3. Division No. 2017092701

    Passed87 members voted

    Motion for closure on Second Reading of Bill 139

    FOR · 50AGAINST · 37

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    50For

    • Liberal50

    37Against

    • PC23
    • NDP13
    • Independent1
  4. Division No. 2017092702

    Passed87 members voted

    Second Reading of Bill 139

    FOR · 86AGAINST · 1

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    86For

    • Liberal50
    • PC23
    • NDP13

    1Against

    • Independent1