Bill lets monthly papers run legal notices

Summary#

Bill 78, the Supporting Ontario’s Community, Rural and Agricultural Newspapers Act, 2019, would amend seven Ontario laws; it does not create a separate program or agency. It would let certain legal notices be published in newspapers issued monthly or more often, rather than only in newspapers issued weekly or more often. The bill’s stated goal is to help community newspapers and municipalities reach people in rural and remote areas.

  • For the City of Toronto Act, the Municipal Act and the Ontario Heritage Act, it adds definitions that include publications issued at regular intervals of a month or less, if they are printed, circulated to the general public and mainly contain news of current events.
  • It makes similar changes to the definitions used in regulations under the Environmental Assessment Act and the Planning Act.
  • Under the Development Charges Act, if regulations require notice of a council meeting to be published in a newspaper, the council must publish it in a document meeting the bill’s broader criteria.
  • Under the Expropriations Act, an authority applying to expropriate land must serve each registered owner and publish the notice three successive times in a qualifying newspaper in the locality. If a person’s address is unknown, the bill allows service by three successive publications in a local newspaper issued monthly or more often.

What it means for you#

  • Community, rural and agricultural newspapers: A paper issued monthly or more often could qualify for certain legal notices if it meets the bill’s other criteria. The bill does not require authorities to choose a particular paper.
  • Municipalities and other public authorities: Where the laws or regulations require newspaper publication, they could use a qualifying monthly or more frequent paper. For development-charge meeting notices, the bill says the council must publish in a document that meets its criteria when regulations require newspaper publication.
  • Landowners facing expropriation: The authority would still have to serve registered owners and publish the notice three times. The bill does not change the underlying power to expropriate land.
  • The public: Some notices could appear in less-frequent publications. The bill changes where notices may be published, not the notice topics or the rules for deciding the underlying matters.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill’s preamble says notice revenue could help support local newspapers, but it gives no estimate of revenue or effect.
  • No estimate is provided for costs to municipalities or other authorities.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not say how authorities choose among qualifying newspapers or assess whether a paper reaches the relevant public.
  • It does not set out new rules for notice placement, timing, oversight or reporting.
  • The bill text says it would start on Royal Assent, but the supplied material does not establish whether it passed or received Royal Assent.
  • The parent Acts and relevant regulations were not supplied, so their full current wording and how these changes would interact with existing rules could not be independently verified.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to let smaller local papers remain eligible for legal notices even if they publish less often than weekly.
  • A possible argument for the bill is that local newspapers may help municipalities share information with people in rural or remote areas, as the preamble says.
  • Allowing monthly papers could give public authorities more options for publishing required notices.

Case against#

  • Notices in a less-frequent paper may reach readers later than notices in a weekly paper. The bill does not explain how to address that possible delay.
  • The bill expands which publications can qualify but does not explain how authorities should decide whether a paper is suitable for a particular notice.
  • The bill gives no cost estimate or evidence of how much notice revenue newspapers might receive.