Summary#
Bill 190, the COVID-19 Response and Reforms to Modernize Ontario Act, 2020, was enacted as Chapter 7 of Ontario’s 2020 statutes. It creates the Alternative Filing Methods for Business Act, 2020 and amends 14 other Acts. Its stated goal is to address public health and safety concerns during an emergency and modernize certain legal processes; that goal is not a guaranteed result.
- For filings under named business laws, a Minister, Director or Registrar may permit an alternative filing method. They may also set requirements for documents, signatures, fees, filing methods and records.
- For a limited period tied to Ontario’s March 17, 2020 emergency, the bill changed meeting rules and deadlines for companies, co-operatives, condominiums and other corporations. It allowed electronic meetings and, in specified cases, extra time for annual meetings.
- For condominium meetings during that period, meeting notices and materials could be given electronically even if an owner or mortgagee had not agreed to electronic service.
- It gives the government authority to make rules about electronic school-board meetings and when board members must attend in person. It also temporarily changed a physical-attendance rule for the Centre Jules-Léger Consortium during certain school-closure orders.
- It changes rules for affidavits and notaries, including allowing remote oaths or notarial work only if regulations permit it and set conditions. It also lets the Attorney General delegate some appointment and revocation powers.
- It allowed the Métis Nation of Ontario’s 2020 councillor election to take place up to 90 days after the emergency ended or was disallowed, and allowed certain plan-beneficiary designations to be made electronically.
What it means for you#
- Businesses and corporations: You may be able to file covered documents by a method other than in-person delivery or mail, and use electronic signatures or copies where the applicable official permits them and their requirements are met. The usual filing method remains available.
- Company, co-operative and condominium members: The temporary emergency rules allowed some meetings to be held electronically and extended some annual-meeting deadlines. The rules also changed notice and voting arrangements. They did not remove the duty to provide required financial information at specified annual meetings.
- Condominium owners and mortgagees: During the temporary period, meeting-related notices and materials could be served electronically, even without an agreement to receive them that way.
- School-board members and the public: The bill authorizes future regulations about electronic meetings, physical attendance and participation by the public. It does not itself set all those rules.
- People needing affidavits or notarial services: Remote service is not automatic. It depends on regulations and any conditions they set.
- Taxpayers and the general public: The supplied text does not directly change taxes, general benefits or property ownership.
Money#
No publicly available information.
- The bill allows filing requirements to cover payment of fees, and authorizes regulations to set certain fees for commissioners and notaries. It gives no fee amounts or cost estimates.
- The bill assigns responsibilities and powers to existing officials and organizations. The supplied material does not estimate any staffing or administration costs.
What is unclear#
- The supplied material does not include the parent Acts or current consolidated laws. I cannot verify how the changes compare with current law, or whether later amendments changed them.
- Several emergency meeting rules were temporary: they generally lasted through the emergency and until 120 days after it ended, with possible extensions by regulation. The bill also provides for their repeal on a date set by proclamation. The supplied material does not establish whether those repeal dates have taken effect.
- Filing officials may set important requirements, including which filing methods and signatures they accept. The bill does not set out those detailed requirements.
- Remote oaths and notarial services depend on regulations. The bill does not itself specify when or how they may happen.
- The bill does not give a cost estimate or explain how its administrative costs would be paid.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to let people and organizations complete filings, meetings and legal formalities without needing to attend in person during an emergency.
- A possible argument for temporary deadline extensions is that organizations may need more time to hold annual meetings during emergency disruptions.
- Giving officials flexibility over filing methods could let them set workable formats and technical requirements for different documents.
- Electronic meeting and service rules could allow some decisions and notices to continue when in-person arrangements are difficult.
Case against#
- One concern is that filing officials receive broad power to set requirements, including rules about signatures, filing methods and fees. The bill does not provide all those details in the Act itself.
- Electronic meetings and service may make participation harder for some people. The supplied text does not explain what access or alternative arrangements must be provided.
- The bill does not estimate the cost of new administration, staffing or technology requirements.
- It is unclear which emergency provisions remain part of current law, because the supplied material does not include later legal changes or proclamation information.