Summary#
Bill 12, the Protection for Motor Vehicle Accident Victims and Other Consumers from Unfair Legal Practices Act, 2016, would amend Ontario’s Law Society Act, Insurance Act and Solicitors Act. Its stated goal is to protect consumers in legal and personal-injury matters; the bill does not create a new agency or service.
- For legal services on automobile-related personal injury claims, it would generally bar licensees from paying or receiving referral fees. After a successful claim, they could agree to a fee paid from the client’s legal bill, up to a limit set by regulation.
- It would limit lawyers’ contingency fees on automobile-related injury damages to 33 per cent of the damages recovered. The bill makes the Solicitors Act contingency-fee rules apply to paralegals unless those rules specifically say otherwise.
- It would require written fee agreements to explain clearly and prominently how the fee is calculated. Clients could cancel a contingency-fee agreement at any time, without giving a reason.
- It would bar legal actions to recover certain medical assessment and treatment costs above set amounts. The bill’s wording refers to personal injury generally, although its explanatory note describes this change as applying to automobile injury claims.
What it means for you#
- People hiring a lawyer or paralegal: A written fee agreement would have to explain how the legal fee is calculated. If it is a contingency-fee agreement, you could cancel it at any time. The bill does not say what, if anything, you would owe after cancelling.
- People with automobile-related injury claims: A contingency fee based on a percentage of damages could not exceed 33 per cent of those damages. The bill does not set the permitted referral-fee amount; regulations would do that.
- People seeking compensation for injury-related health costs: You could not bring an action to recover the portion of specified assessment costs above $2,000, or another amount set by regulation. For other medical care and rehabilitation, the limit would depend on guidelines or regulations.
- Lawyers, paralegals and other Law Society licensees: They would face the referral-fee rules for defined automobile-related claims and the fee-disclosure requirements. For a successful claim, the bill allows a referral fee through a contingency-fee agreement, subject to the prescribed limit.
- People or organizations facing a personal-injury claim: The new rule could protect them from legal action to recover health-care costs above the stated limits. The bill does not expressly restrict this rule to automobile injuries.
Money#
No public cost estimate is available in the supplied material.
- The bill provides no direct appropriation or public spending amount.
- It sets a $2,000 threshold for some assessment costs, but allows regulations to set another amount. It does not state the limit for other medical care and rehabilitation; that would be set in guidelines or regulations.
- The bill does not state the maximum referral fee; regulations would set it. It limits specified contingency fees to 33 per cent of damages recovered.
What is unclear#
- The Law Society Act, Insurance Act and Solicitors Act as they currently operate were not supplied, so the existing rules and the full change from current law could not be verified.
- The bill defines which automobile-related claims are covered by the referral-fee and contingency-fee rules. But the new health-cost section says “personal injury” without an automobile limit, despite the explanatory note’s narrower description.
- The bill does not set the referral-fee limit or the health-cost limits beyond the stated $2,000 threshold. Those details depend on later regulations or guidelines.
- The bill does not explain how a client’s cancellation of a contingency-fee agreement affects payment for work already done.
- The bill says it would start on Royal Assent, but the supplied material does not establish whether it became law.
Case for#
- A possible argument for the bill is that clear, prominent fee disclosures could help clients understand what they will pay.
- Letting a client cancel a contingency-fee agreement at any time could give clients more control over that arrangement.
- Restricting referral fees could reduce financial incentives for licensees to direct clients to one another.
- Limits on recoverable health-care costs could reduce disputes over unusually high assessment or treatment charges.
Case against#
- One concern is that a 33 per cent ceiling could limit the fee a lawyer or paralegal may charge for recovering damages, even when a case requires substantial work.
- The health-cost rule could leave an injured person unable to recover costs above the set limits through an action, even if those costs were incurred.
- The referral-fee ban has an exception for successful claims, but the bill leaves the permitted amount to regulations. The practical limit is therefore not clear from the bill alone.
- It is unclear why the health-cost section is worded to cover personal-injury claims generally when the explanatory note describes it as an automobile-claim measure.