Summary#
Bill 103, the Personal Injury and Accident Victims Protection Act, 2017, would amend Ontario’s Law Society Act and Solicitors Act. Its stated goal is to protect people making personal injury claims by changing rules on referrals, advertising and legal fees.
- Licensees (people authorized to practise law) could not pay or accept referral fees for arranging legal representation on a personal injury claim. Referrals would require the client’s express written consent, and the referring licensee would have to keep the client’s information confidential, except as the consent allows.
- The Law Society of Upper Canada would have to review personal injury legal-service advertisements submitted for approval and approve those that meet the stated standards.
- Contravening the referral or advertising rules could lead to a fine of up to $100,000 on conviction.
- Solicitor fee agreements would have to explain how fees are calculated in a clear, understandable and prominent way. Contingency fee agreements would have to be in writing and include the calculation method.
- A client could cancel a contingency fee agreement within 10 days, without giving a reason.
- For contingency fee agreements based on a percentage of damages in a bodily-injury or death proceeding, total solicitor compensation—including other fees—could not exceed 15% of the amount or value recovered. The solicitor would have to reimburse any excess. This cap would apply to agreements made on or after Royal Assent.
What it means for you#
- People with personal injury or death claims: A lawyer referring you to another lawyer would need your express written consent and would have to keep your information confidential, subject to what you consent to share. The bill does not change your right to bring a claim or set the amount of damages.
- Clients signing contingency fee agreements: You would have 10 days to cancel without a reason. For the specified percentage-based agreements, the solicitor’s total compensation would be capped at 15% of what is recovered.
- Lawyers and law firms: They would have to follow the referral and advertising rules and give the required fee information. The bill does not set out a client application or review process.
- The Law Society: It would review submitted advertisements and approve those meeting the bill’s conditions. The bill does not create a new independent organization.
Money#
No publicly available information on the bill’s public cost.
- The Law Society would have to review advertisements submitted for approval, but the bill gives no staffing or cost estimate.
- A solicitor who receives compensation above the cap would have to reimburse the client. A person convicted of contravening the specified rules could be fined up to $100,000.
What is unclear#
- The parent Acts were not supplied, so I could not verify the current rules or precisely compare them with the bill’s changes.
- The bill leaves details of the Law Society’s advertisement review process to its by-laws; it does not state review timelines.
- The material does not say whether the bill passed. Its text says the changes would start on Royal Assent.
- The bill does not estimate compliance costs for lawyers or firms.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to reduce financial incentives in referrals by banning referral fees for personal injury claims.
- Requiring express written consent for referrals could give clients more control over who represents them.
- Clearer fee disclosures and a 10-day cancellation period could help clients understand and reconsider agreements.
- A stated compensation cap could limit what solicitors collect under the covered contingency fee agreements.
Case against#
- A fixed 15% cap could limit how fees reflect the work involved in different cases; the bill does not explain how that trade-off would be handled.
- Advertisement approval would add a review duty for the Law Society, but the bill does not set review timelines.
- The bill does not explain how the referral ban might affect clients who rely on lawyers to connect them with another lawyer.
- The bill sets a maximum fine but does not describe the enforcement process in detail.