Summary#
Bill 92, the Labour Relations Amendment Act (Replacement Workers), 2019, would amend Ontario’s Labour Relations Act, 1995 by adding rules on replacement workers, reinstatement and benefits during strikes and lock-outs. Its stated goal is to restore protections against replacing striking or locked-out employees. The supplied explanatory note says those protections were later repealed, but the current Act was not supplied, so I could not verify what the law now says.
- Employers could not use striking or locked-out employees for their usual work, or use specified replacement workers to do that work. The rules apply to a lock-out or to a lawful strike with a vote in which at least 60% of those voting authorize the strike.
- The restrictions cover new hires and people engaged after bargaining notice or bargaining begins, as well as certain workers from other sites, later transfers, outside workers and people supplied by another employer. There are separate limits for managers.
- Employers could use replacement workers only for listed care, shelter, emergency and dispatch services, or as needed to prevent danger to life, health or safety, serious damage to equipment or premises, or serious environmental damage. Notice and an opportunity for the union to offer willing and able bargaining-unit employees would usually be required.
- The bill would protect employees from reprisals for refusing replacement work. It would also set reinstatement rules after a strike or lock-out and allow unions to keep non-pension benefits going by tendering enough payment.
- The Board could decide whether an exception applies, set limits on replacement-worker use, and enforce agreements between an employer and union about such use.
What it means for you#
- Employers: During a covered strike or lock-out, you would face limits on who can do bargaining-unit work. You could use replacement workers for the listed services or serious risks only within the bill’s conditions. The bill would put the burden on you to prove you did not breach the general restrictions.
- Unions and striking or locked-out employees: A union could consent to bargaining-unit employees doing some or all of the proposed exception work, if they are willing and able. After a strike or lock-out, employees would generally return to the jobs they held before it, subject to seniority and available-work rules.
- Other employees at the worksite: An employer could not require you to do striking or locked-out employees’ work without your agreement. It could not punish or threaten you for refusing.
- Employees’ benefits: A union could tender payments sufficient to continue non-pension benefits. If it does, the employer or other recipient must accept them and take the steps needed to continue coverage. The bill also bars denying a benefit the employee was already entitled to claim before the strike or lock-out.
- Employers and unions: They could make a written agreement about replacement-worker use for specified work. It could set aside some of the bill’s notice and consent rules, but would expire after the first strike or lock-out ending after the agreement, or when the parties next make or renew a collective agreement, whichever comes first.
Money#
No publicly available information on estimated costs is included in the supplied material.
- The bill does not set out a public appropriation, fee or fine.
- A union choosing to continue benefits would have to tender enough payment; the recipient would have to accept it.
- Employer, union and enforcement costs are not estimated.
What is unclear#
- The bill does not explain the full meaning of some terms it uses, including “serious” damage, “necessary” work and “reasonable opportunity.”
- It gives no detailed process or deadlines for Board decisions, or for deciding how many replacement workers or what level of service is allowed. The Board could also defer an application.
- The bill refers to an exception in another part of the Labour Relations Act when listing who may be used at a strike location. That part of the Act was not supplied, so I could not verify the exception’s scope.
- The bill says it starts on Royal Assent but gives no date by which that would occur. Passage is not assured by the supplied material.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to prevent employers from using replacement workers in a way that weakens employees’ ability to strike or bargain.
- Its exceptions allow replacement-worker use for specified care and emergency services and to prevent serious risks, while giving unions a chance to supply willing and able bargaining-unit employees.
- Reinstatement and benefit rules could give employees clearer protections during and after a work stoppage.
Case against#
- One concern is that the restrictions cover a wide range of people and work arrangements, including some workers from other sites and people supplied by another employer.
- The exceptions may not cover every situation where an employer believes it needs replacement workers; the bill’s limits could make it harder to maintain operations in those cases.
- The Board’s decisions could shape how the exceptions work, but the bill does not set out detailed decision timelines or criteria for some key terms.
- Reinstatement rules may require employers to displace people who performed strike work, subject to the bill’s seniority and other limits.