Labor reform curbs replacement workers

Summary#

Bill 34, the Labour Relations Amendment Act (Replacement Workers), 2018, would amend Ontario’s Labour Relations Act, 1995. It would add restrictions on using replacement workers during strikes and lock-outs, along with rules for emergencies, reinstatement and employment benefits. Its stated goal is to restore restrictions that the bill says were repealed in 1995.

  • Employers could not use striking or locked-out bargaining-unit employees to do other work, or use certain newly hired people and other workers to replace them.
  • The restrictions would apply to a lock-out or to a strike authorized by a vote in which at least 60% of those voting support the strike.
  • Employers could use specified replacement workers only as needed for listed services or to prevent danger, serious damage or serious environmental harm. Notice to the union and an opportunity for it to offer willing and able bargaining-unit employees would generally be required.
  • When a strike or lock-out ends, employers would have to reinstate affected employees under rules based on their former jobs and, when work is limited, seniority or length of service.
  • A union could keep employment benefits in effect by tendering enough money to cover them; the employer or other recipient would have to accept the payment and take the steps needed to continue coverage.

What it means for you#

  • Employers: During a covered strike or lock-out, you would face limits on using replacement workers. These include people hired or engaged after bargaining starts or notice to bargain is given, certain workers from other locations, transferred workers, and people supplied by another employer. At the strike or lock-out location, the bill also restricts using managers from other locations. It does not ban every form of replacement work: it allows specified use for the services and risks listed in the bill.
  • Unions: For permitted emergency or service-related work, you would have a chance to consent to bargaining-unit employees doing the work instead, if they are willing and able. The union could apply with the employer to the Labour Relations Board for directions about whether and how replacement workers may be used.
  • Striking or locked-out employees: If you are not reinstated under an agreement with your employer, the bill would give you a right to return to your former position, subject to limits where there is not enough work or operations need to start up. It would also protect benefits if the union tenders enough to continue them.
  • Employees asked to do replacement work: An employer could not require you to do that work without your agreement. The bill would bar reprisals for refusing.
  • Taxpayers and the public: The bill would not create a new public agency. It would give the existing Labour Relations Board powers to decide disputes and issue directions.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill would require employers or benefit-plan payment recipients to accept sufficient union payments to continue covered employment benefits.
  • It gives no estimate for added Board workload, staffing or other public costs.

What is unclear#

  • The Labour Relations Act, 1995 is not supplied, so the bill’s claimed restoration and its changes compared with current law could not be verified.
  • The bill does not define terms such as “emergency” or “serious deterioration.”
  • It does not set a minimum share of all bargaining-unit members who must vote in a strike vote; it sets a 60% threshold among those who vote.
  • The bill does not give a deadline for the union’s opportunity to consent to bargaining-unit employees doing permitted work, beyond saying the union must respond promptly.
  • The amount of Board work, and any funding or staffing for it, is not stated.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to prevent employers from replacing workers during a strike or lock-out, which could preserve the effect of collective action.
  • Its exceptions allow replacement workers for listed services and to prevent serious harm, while limiting their use to what is necessary.
  • Giving unions a chance to offer willing and able bargaining-unit employees for permitted work could limit replacement hiring while allowing essential work to continue.
  • Reinstatement and benefit rules could give employees clearer protections when a strike or lock-out ends.

Case against#

  • The restrictions could make it harder for employers to keep some operations running during a strike or lock-out, including where work is not covered by the listed exceptions.
  • The bill leaves key terms, including “emergency” and “serious deterioration,” undefined, which could lead to disputes about when replacement workers are allowed.
  • The Labour Relations Board could face added applications and enforcement work, but the bill gives no cost or capacity estimate.
  • The 60% support requirement among voters could prevent the replacement-worker restrictions from applying to a strike that does not meet that threshold.