Summary#
Bill 93, St. James Town Act (Residential Tenancies Amendments), 2019, would amend Ontario’s Residential Tenancies Act, 2006. Its stated aims, as described in the explanatory note, are to set aside rent for major repairs, allow written hearings in some tenant applications, and require rent abatements in specified cases. The supplied material does not include the parent Act, so I could not verify how these changes compare with current law.
- Landlords of residential complexes with 10 or more rental units would have to keep a bank account for the complex and deposit a prescribed percentage of rent into it within 30 days. The money could be used only for major repairs, not routine maintenance or repairs made necessary by poor routine maintenance.
- For specified expenses under section 126 of the Act, a landlord could count only the amount exceeding the maintenance-account balance when those expenses were incurred.
- If a tenant asks for a written hearing on an application under section 29, the Landlord and Tenant Board would have to hold one unless the landlord shows a good reason for oral evidence or submissions. The Board would have to make rules for these hearings.
- The Board would have to order rent abatements for specified landlord breaches or activities. It would consider severity and duration, or impact and duration, and the order would apply regardless of how responsible the landlord was.
- Some rental units excluded under section 7(1) of the Act would not be covered by the account and abatement changes. The supplied text does not identify those units.
What it means for you#
- Landlords of larger complexes: You would have to set aside the prescribed share of rent in an account and use it only for qualifying major repairs. The bill does not say how much the prescribed share would be.
- Tenants: If you make an application under section 29, you could request a written hearing. This would not guarantee one if the landlord satisfies the Board that oral evidence or submissions are needed. In specified cases, the Board would have to order a rent abatement.
- Landlords and tenants: The bill adds illegal entry by a landlord, superintendent, or landlord’s agent to a provision in section 31. The parent Act was not supplied, so the full effect of that change cannot be verified.
- The Board: It would have to set rules for the written hearings. The bill does not create a general written-hearing process for every Board case.
Money#
No cost estimate or prescribed deposit percentage is available in the supplied material.
- Landlords would have to hold part of rent in a restricted account, but the bill does not state the percentage or estimate the cost of setting up or maintaining accounts.
- The bill would limit the specified expenses a landlord can count under section 126: only the amount above the account balance at the time the expenses were incurred.
- Rent abatements would reduce rent payable in the cases covered by the bill. The amount would be at least any minimum set by regulation, if regulations set one.
- The maintenance-account requirement would start three months after Royal Assent. The other provisions would start on Royal Assent.
What is unclear#
- What percentage of rent must be deposited, and whether regulations would set minimum abatement amounts.
- Which rental units are excluded under section 7(1); the supplied bill text omits their descriptions.
- What counts as a “major repair” beyond the exclusions listed in the bill.
- What “good reason” would justify an oral hearing, and how the Board would decide that question.
- How the changes would interact with existing rent-increase rules and other repair programs. The parent Act was not supplied, so this could not be checked.
Case for#
- The account requirement could reserve funds for major repairs instead of leaving the money available for other uses.
- Excluding repairs made necessary by poor routine maintenance could encourage landlords to keep up with regular maintenance.
- Written hearings on request could give tenants another way to present their applications, while allowing oral hearings when the landlord shows a good reason.
- Mandatory abatements could give tenants a remedy when the Board finds one of the specified breaches or activities.
Case against#
- The bill leaves the deposit percentage and key rules to regulations, so landlords and tenants cannot tell from the bill how much money would be set aside.
- A restricted account could leave landlords with less flexibility to pay other costs, while the bill does not explain how urgent repairs would be handled if the account lacked enough money.
- Mandatory abatements apply regardless of the degree to which the landlord was responsible for the breach. That could require an abatement even where the landlord had limited responsibility.
- Written hearings may make it harder to assess evidence that would otherwise be given orally; the bill does not explain how the Board should weigh that concern.