Summary#
Bill 119, the Fostering Privacy Fairness Act, 2022, would amend Ontario’s Child, Youth and Family Services Act, 2017. It would limit disclosure of identifying information about people who received services under that Act once they are 21, and require the Minister to arrange for certain records to be removed from listed organizations and stored under rules set by regulation. The stated goal, reflected in the bill’s short title, is to foster privacy fairness.
- Service providers and lead agencies could not disclose identifying information or reports about a former service recipient aged 21 or older, subject to exceptions in the bill.
- The listed exceptions allow disclosure to the individual, with the individual’s consent, or by court order. A further category of covered information in paragraph 3 is not expressly included in those exceptions.
- The Minister must ensure that covered records held by the Ministry, service providers, lead agencies or the Child Protection Information Network are removed from their possession promptly after the person turns 21 and stored under regulations.
- The bill allows regulations to set storage rules. It does not say that records must be destroyed.
What it means for you#
- People who received services under the Act: At age 21, identifying information and reports about you would be subject to new disclosure limits for service providers and lead agencies. The bill does not set out a process for requesting disclosure or challenging a decision.
- Service providers and lead agencies: They would have to follow the disclosure limits and the Minister’s arrangements for removing and storing covered records. The limits apply despite existing reporting and public-information requirements in sections 56 to 58.
- The Ministry and Child Protection Information Network: The Minister must ensure covered records in their possession are removed and stored under regulations. The bill does not directly impose the same disclosure ban on these two entities.
- General public: The bill could limit access to identifying information in reports that service providers or lead agencies would otherwise make public. It does not change eligibility for services under the Act.
Money#
No publicly available information on the cost.
- The Minister would have to ensure records are removed and stored, which may require staff time or other resources; the bill gives no estimate.
- The bill does not appropriate a specific amount of money or set a fee.
What is unclear#
- The bill does not define key terms such as “identifies” or specify how to handle records that identify more than one person.
- Paragraph 3 also prohibits disclosure of information or reports that refer to and identify a person aged 21 or older, but the listed exceptions apply only to paragraphs 1 and 2. The bill does not explain this difference.
- The bill leaves storage details to regulations, which are not included in the supplied material. It does not say where records would be stored, for how long, or who could access them.
- The bill requires records to be removed from the listed entities’ possession, but does not say whether they must be destroyed or whether copies held elsewhere are covered.
- The supplied material does not include the full current Act, so the existing requirements described in the explanatory note could not be checked against the Act text.
- The bill would start on a date set by proclamation; no start date is provided.
Case for#
- A possible argument for the bill is that people who received services as children or youth should have greater control over the disclosure of information that identifies them as adults.
- Limiting disclosure despite existing reporting and public-information requirements could reduce the chance that identifying details are shared through those channels.
- Requiring records to be removed from the listed organizations after age 21 could reduce the number of places holding them, while still requiring storage under rules.
Case against#
- One concern is that the bill’s limits and exceptions do not clearly cover all information described in its three prohibited categories.
- The bill does not set out storage, access, or retention rules itself, leaving important privacy protections and practical details to future regulations.
- Restricting identifying information in reports could reduce public access to information that service providers or lead agencies currently must make available.
- The Minister must ensure records are removed and stored, but the bill gives no cost estimate or detail about how the work would be done.