Privacy protections limit disclosures of welfare records

Summary#

Bill 237, titled in its text the Fostering Privacy Fairness Act, 2020 (the supplied bill listing calls it 2021), would amend Ontario’s Child, Youth and Family Services Act, 2017. Its stated goal is to limit disclosure of identifying information about people who received services under that Act once they are 21 or older.

  • Service providers and lead agencies could not disclose covered identifying information or reports about those adults, despite existing reporting and public-information rules.
  • The bill allows disclosure of information and reports in two listed categories to the individual, with the individual’s consent, or if a court orders it. The exception does not expressly mention a third category of covered material.
  • The Minister must ensure that covered information and reports are removed from the Ministry, service providers, lead agencies and the Child Protection Information Network promptly after the person turns 21, then stored under rules to be set by regulation.
  • The bill does not set the storage rules or say who would hold the material after it is removed.

What it means for you#

  • Adults who received services: Once you are 21 or older, service providers and lead agencies could not disclose covered information that identifies you, subject to the bill’s stated exceptions. The text does not explain how you would request your information.
  • Service providers and lead agencies: They would have to follow the disclosure ban. The bill’s removal rule also covers information in their possession.
  • The Ministry and Child Protection Information Network: The Minister must ensure covered information is removed from their possession and stored under regulations. The bill does not directly impose the same disclosure ban on the Ministry or the Network.
  • People and organizations receiving reports: The bill would override existing reporting and public-information requirements for covered material. The supplied explanatory note says sections 56–58 currently require certain reporting and public disclosure; the parent Act was not supplied, so that current-law description could not be checked against the Act itself.
  • Everyone affected: The bill does not specify an application, review, appeal or notice process. It would start only on a day set by proclamation.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The Minister would have to ensure information is removed and stored, which may require administrative work. No staffing plan or cost estimate is given.
  • The bill provides for storage rules to be made by regulation but does not state their cost.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not define what it means for a report or information to “identify” a person.
  • The exceptions apply to the first two listed categories of material, but not expressly to the third category, which covers information or reports that refer to and identify the person.
  • The bill does not say where or with whom the material would be stored, who could access it, or how long it would be kept. Those details are left to regulations, which were not supplied.
  • The bill does not explain how its disclosure ban would work with existing reporting and public-information duties beyond saying it applies despite sections 56–58.
  • The bill does not say how a person would receive their information or how consent would be recorded.
  • The supplied material does not include the parent Act, so the existing rules and any overlap with other provisions could not be independently verified.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to protect the privacy of adults who received services as children or young people.
  • A possible argument for the bill is that limiting disclosure after age 21 gives these adults more control over identifying information about them.
  • Requiring covered material to be removed from several listed holders could reduce the number of places where it remains in their possession.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the bill does not set clear storage, access or retention rules in its own text, leaving important protections to future regulations.
  • The ban could limit reporting or public disclosure that the existing Act requires, but the bill does not explain how affected reporting would work.
  • The exceptions do not expressly cover the third category of material, which could make the scope of permitted disclosures uncertain.
  • The Minister’s duty to ensure removal could create administrative costs, but the bill provides no estimate or plan.