Summary#
Bill 302, the Making the Patient Ombudsman an Officer of the Assembly Act, 2021, would amend Ontario’s Excellent Care for All Act, 2010. Its stated goal is to make the patient ombudsman an officer of the Legislative Assembly, with appointment and reporting shifted from the government to the Assembly and its Speaker.
- The Assembly would appoint the patient ombudsman by order. The bill does not create a new agency.
- The Assembly could revoke the appointment for cause, but only by a vote of at least two-thirds of its members.
- The Board of Internal Economy would set the ombudsman’s salary, other pay and benefits.
- If the position is vacant, or the ombudsman cannot or will not perform the duties, the Assembly could appoint a temporary ombudsman for up to six months. If the Assembly is not in session, the Board of Internal Economy could do so.
- The ombudsman would have to report to the Speaker at least annually and at other times the ombudsman considers appropriate. The Speaker would have to table the reports in the Assembly.
What it means for you#
- Patients: The bill does not directly change patient rights or the ombudsman’s complaint-handling powers in the amendments provided. The Excellent Care for All Act was not supplied, so those powers could not be checked against current law.
- Patient ombudsman: Appointment, removal, pay and reporting arrangements would change. The person holding the job when the Act receives Royal Assent would stay in office until their term expires or the Assembly revokes their appointment.
- Assembly and its Speaker: The Assembly would appoint the ombudsman and could remove them for cause with a two-thirds vote. The Speaker would receive the reports and arrange for them to be tabled.
- Board of Internal Economy: It would set the ombudsman’s pay and benefits, and could appoint a temporary ombudsman while the Assembly is not in session.
Money#
No cost estimate is available in the supplied material.
- The Board of Internal Economy must set the ombudsman’s salary or other pay and benefits, including severance, termination, retirement and pension rights.
- The bill provides no estimate of the cost of those amounts or of temporary appointments.
What is unclear#
- The bill does not define “for cause.” The supplied material does not show whether the current Act defines it.
- The bill does not set out how candidates would be selected or how long a new appointment would last; the current Act was not supplied to check whether it covers those details.
- The bill does not specify how a temporary ombudsman would be chosen beyond naming who may appoint one and setting a maximum term.
- The transition provision refers to a “Making the Patient Ombudsman an Officer of the Assembly Act, 2020,” while this bill is titled as a 2021 Act. The supplied material does not explain the difference.
- The bill says it would start on Royal Assent. The supplied material does not say whether it received Royal Assent.
Case for#
- Moving appointment and reporting to the Assembly could make the ombudsman less directly tied to the government department the office reports on.
- Requiring a two-thirds vote to remove the ombudsman for cause could make removal harder to use for ordinary political disagreement.
- Annual reporting to the Speaker would give the Assembly a regular route to receive information about the ombudsman’s activities and recommendations.
Case against#
- The bill does not explain how the Assembly would choose an ombudsman. That leaves an important part of the appointment process unclear.
- “For cause” is not defined in the bill text provided, leaving uncertainty about the grounds for removal.
- If the Assembly is not sitting, the Board of Internal Economy could appoint a temporary ombudsman. The bill does not explain how that temporary appointment would be coordinated with a later Assembly appointment.