Summary#
Bill 65, the Brunt and Kendall Act (Ensuring Safe Firefighter and Trainee Rescue Training), 2021, would amend Ontario’s Fire Protection and Prevention Act, 1997 and Private Career Colleges Act, 2005. Its stated goal is safer rescue and emergency-services training for firefighters and firefighter trainees. If passed, it would create safety standards, course certification and enforcement rules; it would not itself set all the details, which may be set by regulation.
- The Fire Marshal would have to develop and publish minimum safety standards, certify courses before they are offered, and maintain public lists of certified courses and licensed private providers.
- Fire chiefs would have to ensure courses provided within their fire departments meet the bill’s requirements. These courses would also need certification.
- Private providers (providers outside the listed public colleges, registered private career colleges and fire departments) would need a licence, liability insurance and a written contract with each trainee or firefighter they train.
- The Minister would have to establish an expert committee to review the standards. The Fire Marshal would have to consider its recommendations, report on them and publish that report.
- Inspectors could enter and inspect land and premises without a warrant to check compliance, and could order a course to stop if it is uncertified, unsafe or run by an unlicensed private provider.
What it means for you#
- Firefighters and trainees: Any rescue training course offered to you would have to meet the minimum safety standards and be certified before it is offered. If a private provider runs it, you must have a written contract with that provider. The bill does not require you to take a course.
- Fire chiefs and fire departments: Fire chiefs would have to ensure courses provided within their department follow the new requirements. The bill’s injury-reporting duty would not apply to courses provided to firefighters within fire departments.
- Private providers: You would need a licence to offer or provide courses, and would have to meet insurance and other requirements. You would have to report course deaths and injuries to the Fire Marshal within 48 hours. Only the Fire Marshal could issue written confirmation of successful completion of a course provided by a private provider.
- Private career colleges: The Superintendent could not approve a rescue training course unless it is certified. If certification ends, the Superintendent would have to revoke the college’s approval to provide it.
- Fire Marshal and inspectors: The Fire Marshal would gain certification, licensing and information-gathering roles. Inspectors could order unsafe or non-compliant courses to stop. The bill does not set the offence penalty amounts; the supplied material does not include the parent Act needed to verify them against current law.
Money#
No cost information is in the available material.
- The Fire Marshal may employ staff considered necessary, but the bill gives no staffing estimate or cost.
- Regulations may set licence and other fees, and private providers would have to pay prescribed fees and maintain liability insurance. The amounts are not in the bill.
What is unclear#
- The bill does not set the required qualifications, licence fees, insurance amounts or application procedures; regulations may supply these details.
- It sets no decision timelines for course certification or licensing, and does not fully set out review or appeal processes. Regulations may add some licensing appeal rights.
- “Significant change” to a course, which would end its certification unless the Fire Marshal determines in advance that the changed course still meets the standards, is not defined.
- The Fire Marshal would have to consider regional and municipal factors, but the bill does not say what differences would justify different standards.
- The start date would be set by proclamation or, if earlier, one year after Royal Assent. The supplied material does not establish whether or when the bill became law.
Case for#
- A possible argument for the bill is that rescue training can involve dangerous activities, and minimum safety standards could set a common safety floor.
- Requiring certification before a course is offered could help ensure that courses meet those standards.
- Expert reviews, public registries and injury reporting could give the Fire Marshal information to update standards and help people identify certified courses and licensed providers.
- Written contracts and signed statements of roles and safety responsibilities could make responsibilities clearer before a training exercise.
Case against#
- The bill creates significant new responsibilities for the Fire Marshal, fire departments, inspectors and private providers, but does not estimate the staffing or costs.
- Key requirements depend on future regulations, so providers cannot tell from the bill alone what qualifications, fees or insurance coverage will be required.
- The Fire Marshal’s role includes setting standards, certifying courses, licensing private providers and potentially revoking certification. The bill does not fully explain the decision process or timelines.
- The bill’s broad course definition includes courses of any duration and whether or not they charge a fee. The required certification could therefore apply to a wide range of training.