Summary#
Bill 58, the Brunt and Kendall Act (Ensuring Safe Firefighter and Trainee Rescue Training), 2018, would amend Ontario’s Fire Protection and Prevention Act, 1997 and Private Career Colleges Act, 2005. Its stated goal is safer rescue and emergency-services training for firefighters and firefighter trainees; it does not create a separate agency.
- The Fire Marshal would have to set and publish minimum safety standards for rescue training courses, consult relevant experts and groups, and keep the standards under review. If no standard is set for a type of rescue, the applicable National Fire Protection Association standard would apply.
- Before a course could be offered, it would have to be certified by the Fire Marshal. Private providers would also need a licence; colleges and people providing courses as part of their fire-department duties are excluded from the bill’s definition of “private provider.”
- A fire chief would have to ensure rescue training courses provided within the department follow the new rules. Before a training exercise, course providers and other people specified by the Fire Marshal would have to sign a document setting out roles and safety responsibilities.
- Private providers would have to use written contracts with trainees or firefighters and give a written record of course fees paid. Only the Fire Marshal could issue written confirmation of successful completion for a course provided by a private provider.
- Inspectors could enter and inspect land or premises without a warrant to check compliance. They could order a course to stop immediately if it is uncertified, unsafe, below the standards, or offered by an unlicensed private provider.
What it means for you#
- Firefighters and firefighter trainees: A rescue training course could not be offered unless it is certified and meets the safety standards. For a private-provider course, you would have to enter a written contract, and only the Fire Marshal could issue written confirmation that you completed it.
- Private providers: You would need a licence and certified courses, and would have to follow licence conditions, including insurance and inspection requirements. You would also have to report deaths or injuries connected to course activities within 48 hours, provide additional information if required, and keep records of fees paid.
- Fire departments and chiefs: Chiefs would have to ensure courses provided within their department follow the new rules. The bill does not require departments to report deaths or injuries from courses provided to firefighters within fire departments.
- Colleges: A private career college could not receive approval to provide a rescue training course unless the course is certified. Its approval would have to be revoked if certification ended.
- Fire Marshal and Minister: The Minister would have to establish an expert committee. The Fire Marshal would have to certify courses, maintain public registries, review the committee’s recommendations, and publish statistics on reported deaths and injuries.
Money#
The bill permits staffing and fees but gives no cost estimate.
- The Fire Marshal could employ as many people as considered necessary, but the bill gives no staffing number or cost.
- Private providers would have to pay any prescribed licensing or other fees and maintain liability insurance. The amounts are not set in the bill.
- The bill does not set course prices or say who would pay them.
What is unclear#
- Regulations would set important details, including licence qualifications and procedures, fees, insurance requirements, and possible exemptions from some or all of the new rules.
- The bill does not set the process or timeline for course certification, or an appeal process for a certification decision.
- The standards, staffing needs, fees, insurance amounts, and costs are not specified.
- The bill would start on a date set by proclamation or, if earlier, one year after Royal Assent. The supplied material does not say whether it received Royal Assent or when it would take effect.
- The parent Acts were not supplied, so the changes could not be checked against the full current wording of those Acts.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to address safety risks in rescue training by requiring minimum standards and course certification before training can be offered.
- A possible argument for requiring expert reviews is that standards would be revisited after changes to national standards and at least once every three years.
- Reporting deaths and injuries could provide the Fire Marshal with information to assess course safety and publish statistics.
- Written safety roles before an exercise could make responsibilities clearer to people conducting or taking part in training.
Case against#
- One concern is that the bill creates mandatory certification and licensing, but does not explain how applications would be handled or how long decisions would take.
- The bill allows fees, insurance requirements, and staffing without setting amounts or estimating costs. The burden on providers and the public is therefore unclear.
- The bill does not require injury and death reports for courses provided to firefighters within fire departments, limiting the information collected about those courses.
- The Fire Marshal could set additional licence conditions, while many details would be left to future regulations. The bill does not show how these powers would work in practice.